# Claims and their evidence

This table applies E1's claims-to-evidence check to this one-room account. It reports existing warrants and validation rather than launching the absent global audit. A source delivery receipt does not certify interpretation. The accepted R4 critic and its repaired contradictions remain part of the record. No later global model, return or independent C5 reader result is available.

| Claim | Carried by | Evidence named | Validation of that kind | Rival and limit | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| `N01`: complementary timed repair can reach locally acknowledged completion | words | `A01`, `F-001`, `c0027`, `c0071`, `E-02`; full connected repair replies | cite 6345 and 6347 confirm the words; R4 read context and checked candidate alternatives | Generic celebration is weaker than the explicit connected reply chain. Failure with the same antecedent remains untested; `E-23` lacks it. No prevalence or deterministic tendency is proved. | Locally supported, thin transfer; fair bounded arrow |
| `N02`: an answered challenge can revise attribution or sanction | words | `A02`, `F-002`, `c0077`, `c0078`, `c0079`, `c0075`, `c0076`, `E-04`, `E-03` | full R4 exchanges; cite 6349 and 6351 confirm the denial/apology pair | Politeness remains a possible account of tone, but the apology explicitly concerns identifying supposed traitors. Pity-based release is not innocence. There is no response-rate evidence or observed ignored denial in the negative samples. | Locally supported, thin transfer; fair bounded arrow |
| `P01` makes a potential contribution addressable without establishing acceptance | words | `c0070`, `c0019`, `c0043`, `E-01`, `E-10`, `E-23` | cite 6339, 6341 and 6343; prior full threads supply missing-plan and refusal context | Guides can be merely relay from external decisions; local addressability does not prove where decisions were made or what everyone read. | Bounded practice |
| `K01` and `F-003`: an undertaking may exceed demonstrated control over the relevant placers | words | `c0308`, `c0306`, `E-05`, `E-09`, `E-11`; promise and subsequent same-speaker disagreement in `dfq3f11` and `dfq7a8j`, thread `62z31i` | cite 6358 and 6360; linked full R4 thread check | Participant inability is an explanation, not a census. A binding arrangement elsewhere remains possible. Opposing speakers do not prove communal conversion. | Specific scope limit, no universal absence |
| `P07`: text reports preservation of a result; migration and header adoption remain unproved | words | `c0296`, `c0300`, `c0289`, `E-21`, `E-24`, `E-25` | cite 6364 plus retained full R2 contexts distinguish request, completed artifacts and further work | A finished artifact can be solitary work. No image, video or header adoption was independently inspected. Silence about later uptake is weak. | Textual persistence only |
| Last observed coordinating attempt and frozen aftermath share | pattern | organizing_end.json; R2 count receipt 1603; distinct coded items `638gop`, `63dplh`, `63eg3x` via `c0289`, `c0297`, `c0299` | instrument aftermath mode used R1's actionable-turn rule: 3/19 distinct coded items strictly after 73 through 97, share 0.15789473684210525; none exactly at 73 or 97. Latest `c0299` at 94.53666666666666. | Coded items are not all raw comments or participants; attempted coordination does not require uptake. R6 cannot rerun the R2-only operation, so this is the preserved result, not a new calculation. | Scoped inherited measurement |
| `F-004`: functional matches do not establish a complete four-problem system for one bounded community | words | mapping-C3.jsonl; `T4-001`, `T4-002`, `c0043`, `c0027`, `c0032`, `c0306`; verified Puranam, Alexy and Reitzig 2014 pp.163 to 166 | R5 compared definitions after the prior and selected model; literature support stays distinct from the empirical passages | Proposed solutions can fail; goals may be implicit; rewards may be intrinsic. Unmapped themes and incomplete membership evidence cannot refute universality. | Bounded comparative inference |

## Measurements, reach and absences

No proposition is a claim of prevalence. Both `N01` and `N02` rest on observed local arrows with mechanisms, not wholly theorised links and not literature-supplied mechanisms. Dated sequence evidence is carried by the linked words and instrument hours; no measured interval is invented. No count validates their causal interpretation. Their position within `D01` does not make them a dimension-level self-arrow or give them one common mechanism.

Coverage is distinct from support. The inherited complete-code census was 308/308 codes, coverage receipt 2225, hours 0 through 97 inclusive with no endpoint codes. That records delivered IDs, not understanding, empirical prevalence or a complete raw-text census. The R3 theme masses remain coverage, not shares of successful arrangements; this account does not use them to rank practices.

All absence claims are weak and specific: no full public inducement mapping is identified; nonreader compliance is not measured; unanswered requests are right-censored; a promised border is limited by a reported contrary sequence; durable migration is not established within this window. External decisions and unspoken motives remain unobserved. No claim that the community lacked all allocation, rewards or control follows.

## What this account did not validate

No population composition result, cross-case onset contrast, theory novelty against comparable organizations, complementarity effect, or C5 reader fidelity score is available. The source coding supplied no independent coder-conflict register; none is fabricated. The two accepted R4 contradictions were repaired, and the rival partition was answered with reasons. Mechanical source, schema and quotation checks do not decide construct validity or mechanism truth.

## Retained measurement metadata

{"mode":"aftermath","unit":"items","n":3,"denominator":{"unit":"items","n":19,"of":"this room's distinct coded items strictly after hour 73 through hour 97"},"receipt":1603,"boundaries":{"start":{"hour":73,"ids":[]},"end":{"hour":97,"ids":[]}}}

{"mode":"coverage","unit":"codes","n":308,"denominator":{"unit":"codes","n":308,"of":"this room's live codes, hours 0 through 97 inclusive"},"receipt":2225,"boundaries":{"start":{"hour":0,"ids":[]},"end":{"hour":97,"ids":[]}}}