# The data structure, final (C5c-13, C5d's work redone after the serial work)

Target length: one row per third-order theme; long, by the rule. The table runs over all five tiers as they finally stand after pass 15: the participant's words, the coder's first-order concept, the coder's second-order theme, the third-order theme it was placed on, the fourth-order theme that gathers it, and the dimension. There is one row for each of the 195 third-order themes that a fourth-order theme gathers, in the order of the dimensions and their themes. Each quote is a concept cited under its third-order theme, entered through `cite.py`, with its community, author handle, hour since the canvas opened and concept id. The rows show the range, not the centre: within each fourth-order theme, members take rooms from the four room-size quartiles in turn. The rule is written in `notes-C5.md`. The generated view over every concept is `_views/data-structure.md`; `structure.md` carries the rest.

| representative quote | first-order concept | second-order theme | third-order theme | fourth-order theme | aggregate dimension |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| "Ok thanks. That sounds pretty cool, actually." (r/gameattack, xOD+kbGXeRp7dno4G++odZfAGZo=, h25.09, c0009) | thanking the explainer and saying it sounds cool | explaining r/place to Reddit noobs | T3-016 explaining what the canvas is | T4-003 Sensemaking | D01 Critical mass |
| "No Tennessee had their own logo higher up to the right" (r/utaustin, CtKqIj4KMDaGECok+TJujOGAoVc=, h77.21, c0145) | explaining Tennessee had its own logo elsewhere | working out what the mark and the talk mean | T3-018 decoding the finished picture's details | T4-003 Sensemaking | D01 Critical mass |
| "Instead we have nice trans flag <3" (r/shitredditsays, JeoPA4qhd+VybXPii0YCVNGCyF8=, h45.07, c0024) | welcoming a nice trans flag | surveying what is showing up and disappearing on the canvas | T3-052 remarking on neighbouring pictures | T4-003 Sensemaking | D01 Critical mass |
| "Would be awesome, we need more man-power though it seems, we're making slow progress while holding off the griefing as is. Start the body though if you want?" (r/ScottPilgrim, MJf+jnayA3ByanNSbJAmQ7yzQNI=, h21.41, c0029) | inviting a body start while warning manpower is already stretched | calling people in and putting pixels to work | T3-002 calling members in to place | T4-005 Mobilization | D01 Critical mass |
| "We are holding for now but we are going to need some help from the main sub to survive the future" (r/placetardis, g6Ac6krAhuq2s0wKkohkeLn8rFw=, h65.16, c0027) | holding for now while seeking main-sub help to survive | bringing helpers together and returning help | T3-062 recruiting kindred subs to help | T4-005 Mobilization | D01 Critical mass |
| "Repairs are going well. Great work, everyone!" (r/monalisaclan, C1/r97eWUWenGSHIK560b/sal64=, h71.99, c0220) | reporting repairs going well and praising everyone | cheering, thanking, and keeping the builders going | T3-104 cheering the builders on | T4-005 Mobilization | D01 Critical mass |
| (no concept is cited under this theme) |  |  | T3-144 recruiting quietly to avoid attackers | T4-005 Mobilization | D01 Critical mass |
| "Yeah, we should wait until we get more people to start" (r/guatemala, s1oisAzxAWorOYFXw4kthXPoGKw=, h52.13, c0004) | waiting for more people before starting | getting more people in and telling the room they started | T3-167 timing a mass placement together | T4-005 Mobilization | D01 Critical mass |
| "Tfw place ended 2 hrs before I discovered this sub." (r/bangladesh, hODCWAAPL7lWWxdVUWaHixFctVg=, h75.36, c0030) | lamenting finding the sub two hours after place ended | looking back on arriving too late | T3-036 judging the canvas too full | T4-012 Collective efficacy | D01 Critical mass |
| "Its over guys just give up." (r/apocalypserising, B1j7qklqXySlj8OOH8N17ZE+Jzs=, h57.15, c0035) | telling the defenders to give up | opening Discord and refusing to give up defending | T3-059 urging others to give up | T4-012 Collective efficacy | D01 Critical mass |
| "I'm honestly kind of surprised that we didn't put up a sprite of a Burst Laser II on r/place, considering how much we fetishize that weapon. Though a Flak I would be an appropriate choice too." (r/ftlgame, v7Y9op7Iy8iJ8ogLmjcrrx6gl64=, h41.95, c0029) | wondering why the room did not draw its fetishized Burst Laser II | wondering why the room did not draw its Burst Laser II | T3-098 questioning the room's canvas presence | T4-012 Collective efficacy | D01 Critical mass |
| "The game itself doesn't have enough population to pull this off." (r/planetside, 952We/kCSvTeiYI4lce9KHS+mvY=, h51.05, c0059) | saying the game lacks enough population to pull it off | testing whether a small crowd can pull it off | T3-136 doubting the room's strength | T4-012 Collective efficacy | D01 Critical mass |
| "everyone has been using scripts man aint nobody gonna sit there placin a block every 5 mins at least not me" (r/egypt, HuH0n/FMVKw0aldd2voHwprGaZU=, h47.80, c0024) | refusing five-minute manual placement because everyone is using scripts | refusing to place a block every five minutes while others use scripts | T3-181 quitting the effort under strain | T4-012 Collective efficacy | D01 Critical mass |
| "Remember guys, the inner eye is clear!" (r/TeamDignitas, oYQlBH5x1U6UZCMWhXVoYtQlHLU=, h9.28, c0006) | reminding builders that the inner eye is clear | working out the yellow-and-black design | T3-004 settling the mark's design | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Let's build this to ward casuels on r/place" (r/truestl, [deleted], h57.69, c0068) | proposing a build to ward off casuels | working out what and where to draw | T3-033 proposing the room's mark | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Would be really cool to make a Mario walk across the whole thing, but perhaps for now making the toadstool near the top on the very left flash from completely red to completely green would be a good start :D" (r/Mario, Vzr7ts9HEviGUIC34Nodk87xQu4=, h71.65, c0011) | scaling a walking Mario idea down to flashing the toadstool red and green | planning to make the toadstool flash | T3-077 animating the mark in timelapse | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Just noticed this on Place" (r/anime, [deleted], h29.48, c0088) | pointing out something noticed on Place | Spotting and locating anime work | T3-082 finding the room's mark placed | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "20 minutes in and going strong :D" (r/SydneyFC, JJY5M1rLO9FSumNI6Qs6osF9zBY=, h71.25, c0012) | reporting it going strong after 20 minutes | writing a small SYD FC and watching whether it lasts | T3-092 making a tribute alone | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Wie im Titel geschrieben fände ich das angemessen um unseren beistand und trauer auszudrücken." (r/placeDE, g/6NmLI9b1bThCzo1tzk9tbuezk=, h69.90, c0274) | proposing Russian colours to express grief and support | making memorials and messages of support | T3-160 building memorials to the dead | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Even if it's just /r/bi?" (r/bisexual, uI7Wk82BLwffBQVgWKWhAOBBxYE=, h64.00, c0107) | suggesting a shortened subreddit label | working out flag sizes, stripes, and text | T3-169 signing the sub's name | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Don't worry we don't invade we only adopt, see yo shi, and the duck" (r/mexico, vCV9V4ZVHwgeAy4336mu0alzQTA=, h47.80, c0200) | saying they adopt rather than invade, as with Yoshi and the duck | protecting and adopting Yoshi, the duck, and the cactus | T3-175 adopting a sign others began | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "I couldn't find a way that fit well without disturbing anyone around us so I gave up" (r/parrots, aQ/wKF7ZP8dhBkYQRooc4fv//dU=, h60.19, c0052) | giving up a name plan that would disturb neighbours | trying and then dropping writing r/parrots | T3-191 leaving the work unsigned | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "'Bow is happy for the ad but doesn't want spam: don't add his name" (r/parahumans, [deleted], h19.77, c0043) | relaying that Bow is happy for the ad but does not want his name added | keeping the canvas project from causing S4hbbQtdz/cRgjTfqcESz5Bj8VM= trouble | T3-197 heeding the creator's wishes | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Need help in putting the Indian flag on r/place canvas" (r/bakchodi, wI7Idw62/GVXK8rM7kiYnP9XqW4=, h11.26, c0016) | asking for help putting the Indian flag on the r/place canvas | asking people to build, fix, and defend the Indian flag | T3-065 building the homeland's flag | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Kan vi få til en ostehøvel?" (r/norge, [deleted], h23.38, c0073) | proposing an ostehøvel for the canvas | making Norwegian things on the canvas | T3-113 drawing national emblems | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Shall we add Uboa to Place?" (r/yumenikki, emEMwAmoZSlJ0lxKR7mjTohoiDs=, h59.53, c0053) | asking whether to add Uboa | building Madotsuki and adding friends and her knife | T3-041 extending the room's work | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "I've almost finished a new one at 605, 772. Help me maintain it?" (r/Slovakia, OCSAr9DOzDE0zUUJcCNT/49OdU4=, h69.29, c0038) | asking for help maintaining a new Slovak heart | protecting nearby art and making Slovak hearts | T3-060 adding a personal piece | T4-006 Collective representation | D02 Coordination without command |
| "I noticed that and I've started to add to it!" (r/pansexual, 1h4At71nHI2BtoNlbqOHjLPWiZc=, h27.55, c0006) | noticing the new flag and adding to it | making pan flags and hearts together | T3-038 building and reporting the mark | T4-007 Direct information sharing | D02 Coordination without command |
| "If you notice any specific users defacing repetitively, send them my way.  Last night, I publicly shamed a repeat defacer to their respective college subreddit and they instantly stopped." (r/Northwestern, eJPeKJNprY/T03ZET4ttfUCmaHU=, h70.86, c0043) | offering to publicly shame repeat defacers in their college subreddit | naming and confronting repeat defacers | T3-008 messaging individual placers to stop | T4-008 Standardization of output | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Want to help, does anyone have the coordinates?" (r/davidbowie, 2kHU5En+vg9PnP+FxZ02mhbywGA=, h44.50, c0009) | wanting to help and asking for coordinates | passing around the template, coordinates, and places to organise | T3-034 asking for coordinates and instructions | T4-008 Standardization of output | D02 Coordination without command |
| "This community is so poorly coordinated it's painful." (r/ss13, xb650tUOPzeOyaRQn8heekeajdM=, h60.47, c0070) | calling the community painfully poorly coordinated | calling the community painfully poorly coordinated | T3-049 complaining the calls are scattered | T4-008 Standardization of output | D02 Coordination without command |
| "You just place down dots of colors in different areas. If we get farther along, it will be easier to follow later, so check back later and see our progress!" (r/schoolidolfestival, Fr8suOpVbTIrF9qlbgsW1oOWJvY=, h38.82, c0044) | explaining how to join once the picture is easier to follow | turning Honoka into guides people can follow | T3-070 sharing coordinates, templates and how-to | T4-008 Standardization of output | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Whats the official Temple place template?" (r/Temple, [deleted], h61.71, c0110) | asking for the official Temple place template | getting everyone onto one plan, template, or script | T3-091 keeping everyone on one template | T4-008 Standardization of output | D02 Coordination without command |
| "I disagree. The Reddit admins said scripts are okay. The platform was left open with an API in place for anyone to use." (r/heyyea, KRnBcMr7np7d0p/mqO1t398jefY=, h77.32, c0015) | defending scripts as allowed and open to anyone | arguing whether scripts ruin the point | T3-027 arguing whether scripts are fair | T4-009 Workarounds | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Mul oli 5 tundi bot peal" (r/eesti, TVqcTx8A0uXCtPE8UuC4aF5bSqc=, h76.06, c0081) | saying they ran the bot for five hours | putting bots and scripts to work on the design | T3-028 running scripts for the work | T4-009 Workarounds | D02 Coordination without command |
| "My hockey team has me tied up, unfortunately we have rivals so it's become a competition." (r/scp, cKA39roRG3PEMw/LKVbJMLSgxBo=, h47.36, c0094) | explaining that a rival hockey-team competition tied up their pixels | keeping the mark up against too few pixels and competing work | T3-074 working around the timer | T4-009 Workarounds | D02 Coordination without command |
| "i have 20 alts, how can i make them all run this?" (r/bitcoin, FS/Q33uMQ3UvwMzI/TMicux8O/o=, h45.30, c0253) | asking how to run the script with twenty alt accounts | Automating placement and reconciling script versions | T3-088 placing beyond the pixel limit | T4-009 Workarounds | D02 Coordination without command |
| "for example, it appears some users are all either operating with an outdated 대한민국! model, or operating with only the original heart model altogether and are literally undoing everyone's hard work every 5 minutes" (r/seolhyun, +4XJxEkR+250gL4R7Eq9Ls4/Ju0=, h65.16, c0036) | blaming outdated models for undoing everyone's work | updating models and scripts so work sticks | T3-089 switching off stale scripts | T4-009 Workarounds | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Here from r/aggies With a script to protect both our logos" (r/utaustin, [deleted], h61.54, c0161) | bringing a script from r/aggies to protect both logos | using overlays and scripts to build and defend | T3-108 sharing one bot target | T4-009 Workarounds | D02 Coordination without command |
| "DM Me if you want to lend any away (or just set them up running)" (r/gatech, w241Kbmc9ioxXRnkAESWhX6repo=, h59.73, c0066) | asking for direct messages to lend accounts | sharing scripts and spare accounts to keep pixels right | T3-120 lending accounts to a bot | T4-009 Workarounds | D02 Coordination without command |
| "IT HAS OVER 5000 upvotes on r/place, it is happening so change your scripts!" (r/afip, tQpVbGenoG5DDHtR1vLUc3TUqpA=, h72.86, c0061) | using r/place upvotes to demand changed scripts | running and changing flag scripts | T3-168 editing scripts to spare neighbours | T4-009 Workarounds | D02 Coordination without command |
| "I just created a discord server" (r/Fez, 1m59w2XCo+fnUfu97x7TtOWPr2U=, h24.81, c0016) | creating a Discord to discuss more easily | finding somewhere to coordinate | T3-014 moving planning into a chat | T4-010 Backstage decision-making | D02 Coordination without command |
| "It was a lot of fun. I tried getting the sneaky discord to do it but we could never coordinate. I'm glad I helped in this one." (r/cloud9, r4UCJUEKWCTpsLdP0HQrXtC8eJk=, h83.58, c0063) | saying the sneaky Discord could not coordinate but this build was fun | remembering a failed Discord plan and a fun build | T3-107 keeping planning in the thread | T4-010 Backstage decision-making | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Why discord? and not a sane thing like IRC?" (r/archlinux, zfV+KcKdsM6WMFuMWW4fbUw+ITA=, h53.71, c0141) | asking why Discord instead of sane IRC | arguing over Discord, IRC, and Slack | T3-109 arguing which chat to use | T4-010 Backstage decision-making | D02 Coordination without command |
| "I'm as free to stay out of the discords/forums and effect the canvas in the way I choose in the same way you are free to make discords and alliances and whatever. It's all part of the art :)" (r/smashbros, xm6sLHDp1qTflPJh8xuz6+ctILk=, h74.57, c0379) | claiming freedom to alter the canvas outside Discord alliances | enforcing and contesting who gets to change the canvas | T3-114 disputing the chat's authority | T4-010 Backstage decision-making | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Those cucks are here apan ko apni bhasha use karni chaihiye jisse apni strategy na pata chale" (r/bakchodi, /MypdloPFuBbhLKm0eqsvqjq1RI=, h72.14, c0118) | asking people to use their own language so opponents cannot learn the strategy | hiding the plan by speaking Hindi | T3-116 hiding the plan from rivals | T4-010 Backstage decision-making | D02 Coordination without command |
| "I was in their Discord for some reason and they were talking about it." (r/porterrobinson, 3Vp5553EbruQqLUner0ORzJ7laQ=, h55.42, c0111) | using Xtrill Discord talk to attribute the attack | blaming and fighting XTrill over the logo | T3-132 spying in a rival's chat | T4-010 Backstage decision-making | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Here is Fred with the grid" (r/giivasunner, x/wX22aYAA+nyRrgGzWM2HVGb24=, h59.92, c0149) | bringing a gridded Fred reference back from the joint chat | moving joint work into Discord and reporting it back | T3-152 announcing what the chat decided | T4-010 Backstage decision-making | D02 Coordination without command |
| "We need to come to a consensus as a group." (r/edboxes, EyN5XsfbbGXImtGAdFyWZwK6B4M=, h71.74, c0075) | calling for group consensus on relocation | deciding whether to move when the bigger alliance closes in | T3-066 putting decisions to a vote | T4-011 Decided order | D02 Coordination without command |
| "I am the new temp leader in the discord chat please don't give up we will not lose our corner" (r/TheGreatGreenBox, wcvJ6c+B6ZpVHtNqkjZtd43NlDU=, h14.64, c0051) | claiming temporary Discord leadership to hold the corner | coordinating through chats, votes and improvised leaders | T3-101 putting one member in charge | T4-011 Decided order | D02 Coordination without command |
| "I think we have too many people working the logo, need more people on the blue.  Gotta box out the others!" (r/tampabaylightning, 8KDk0xkn4AqtOhF1iHJSyzzagKY=, h32.64, c0061) | redirecting too many logo workers to box others out with blue | teaching and assigning the pixel jobs | T3-103 dividing the picture among teams | T4-011 Decided order | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Yo solo saque captura de cada pixel que cambiaron, para el Wall of Shame." (r/argentina, EU20pCBWynruFzQd4yiGRA8Z/ME=, h26.96, c0153) | capturing changed pixels for the Wall of Shame | policing who belongs, who helped and who gets blamed | T3-121 excluding the room's own vandals | T4-011 Decided order | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Nope, just refresh and click :l" (r/monstercat, siyCx2ImPmVgzhHILZhaTF2K5kI=, h31.62, c0249) | keeping coordination on the canvas by refreshing and clicking | keeping coordination on the canvas instead of Discord | T3-125 saying the room wings it | T4-011 Decided order | D02 Coordination without command |
| "It's a new April Fools and this is a chance to renew your oaths and for new warriors to join our ranks!" (r/AprilKnights, Pw9mxeNADOEkMEuIXOSjdgPEugM=, h26.94, c0041) | renewing oaths and bringing in new warriors | Renewing the order for another April | T3-172 renewing the order's oaths | T4-011 Decided order | D02 Coordination without command |
| "A principle of the Green Corner is democracy, always." (r/GreenCorner, zQbh5nv68Fum7wb/DuNhPnnQU/w=, h22.65, c0106) | defending democracy even during attack | electing leaders and letting polls decide | T3-173 holding elections for office | T4-011 Decided order | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Discuss proposals related to our logo on /r/place here." (r/haskell, W9W1lWr9pub1eEiQlHehzEamSMk=, h54.81, c0057) | opening a committee thread for proposals about the r/place logo | handing the pixels to the community and opening a committee | T3-187 handing the work over | T4-011 Decided order | D02 Coordination without command |
| "Man I'm sorry I couldn't help. So busy these days lol. But I will do my best to defend it" (r/Jamaica, we6VyHCwaw4Noj2C6UIml1qDBdc=, h57.47, c0034) | apologising for missing the build and promising to defend it | handing over and defending the flag | T3-005 defending the work against attackers | T4-013 Repair work | D03 Maintenance |
| "Yeah I've been trying to fix it for a while but someone keeps putting it back to the current state." (r/muse, ia1Y/f0FW5lXAtcaYlq0b5xYk7k=, h40.73, c0065) | having logo fixes repeatedly reverted | guarding and repairing what we have | T3-021 watching and repairing the work | T4-013 Repair work | D03 Maintenance |
| "The era of expansionism is over, as fun as it was. We want to be seen as an independent artwork rather than a carpet for others to put their things on." (r/SquareSpiral, F5Vsof8pM3p3HnGrKvPeVvfP6cQ=, h62.47, c0186) | ending expansionism to become independent artwork | setting tasks, roles, and boundaries together | T3-042 choosing upkeep over expansion | T4-013 Repair work | D03 Maintenance |
| "voids can easily eat up the F if it's black so colour has to be changed." (r/formula1, NEjQyPA/kCqZJalT785kpUVlWAA=, h63.45, c0384) | changing the F to grey so the void cannot eat it easily | fighting the void and holding the logo | T3-055 reshaping the mark against tampering | T4-013 Repair work | D03 Maintenance |
| "C'est dommage d'avoir deux projets, surtout vu que nous ne sommes pas vraiment très nombreux.. Tu veux pas nous rejoindre ou tu es vraiment proche d'y arriver ?" (r/bretagne, Iq+Omxd9ke38Y0PfxklKZSBiMSQ=, h49.45, c0025) | demandant de réunir deux projets faute de monde | réunissant deux projets faute de monde | T3-069 concentrating effort on fewer pieces | T4-013 Repair work | D03 Maintenance |
| "It's 3am here in Texas and I'm fucking tired but don't want to give up just yet." (r/PinkVomitMonster, h1nzRwpW2A81ip23wbwUcb3slmM=, h16.26, c0010) | staying up tired rather than giving up | staying up and thanking the guardians | T3-141 covering the night shift | T4-013 Repair work | D03 Maintenance |
| "i think its from the college football sub" (r/teamcube, 0FkmTfqUhHSz+NOj7dyqqxrL+Fo=, h59.37, c0017) | identifying the red S with the college football sub | clearing and expanding into contested space | T3-087 tracing who changed the work | T4-019 Attribution | D03 Maintenance |
| "Admins changed the algorithm to keep party parrot off the front page. Let's show them what we think of that" (r/partyparrot, V/h98RdkFmCx45VX4RfF8vaN9CI=, h26.40, c0027) | calling on the room to answer an alleged front-page algorithm change | answering the alleged front-page change by partying and welcoming r/all | T3-118 blaming moderators for a loss | T4-019 Attribution | D03 Maintenance |
| "<3 and tbh idk how it got that messy but we're under attack!! (lol not really but people are messing up the logo occasionally)" (r/bangtan, XYG2xYSZi3naeNIrqcjWVxS3eEk=, h55.12, c0070) | joking that they are under attack while reporting people messing up the logo | sorting attacks from mistakes | T3-170 mistaking friendly work for vandalism | T4-019 Attribution | D03 Maintenance |
| "ADILI PEMBELOT YANG MEMULAI PERANG TANPA ABA-ABA!!!!!" (r/indonesia, qW1kOmHd5um+Eo3PIjB9P0FvNfw=, h82.17, c0218) | demanding trial for defectors who began war without orders | blaming attackers, rogues and unauthorized fighters | T3-188 disowning placers outside the plan | T4-019 Attribution | D03 Maintenance |
| "Michigan has given us a bit more room so lets make a bigger **I**! This one is slightly bigger and doesn't have any grey." (r/uiowa, 889JxMh5oEN5kS0Cn/BodCuCIuo=, h59.84, c0012) | making a bigger I in room Michigan gave | trading help and room with neighbors | T3-012 granting a neighbour room | T4-014 Territoriality | D04 Order without law |
| "Would it fit at 981, 433? Those pixels haven't been touched in half a day" (r/latin, YmWaqXLH6BHFI1M6E2gSAKb7E6g=, h55.37, c0021) | suggesting pixels that had gone untouched | moving SPQR until finding room | T3-020 choosing a canvas spot | T4-014 Territoriality | D04 Order without law |
| "We've moved to the top left corner! Help continue our too shoutout on /r/place :)" (r/toolband, [deleted], h37.30, c0062) | announcing a move to the top-left corner and asking help for the Tool shout-out | finding and moving the Tool mark when a spot fails | T3-022 relocating after losing the spot | T4-014 Territoriality | D04 Order without law |
| "Your script isn't creating anything other than a purple and grey line of crap coming to fuck up other stuff, change it or move it somewhere else." (r/KState, C24aG1TtgtDcvOrXBqE/JU8rMMA=, h48.14, c0007) | telling KSU its script is messing up other work and must move | moving when other pictures have the space | T3-039 yielding space when asked | T4-014 Territoriality | D04 Order without law |
| "looks like poland is trying to take it back" (r/bahrain, 6cQdM+wV41+M5iGnRwfKgQZSJuY=, h66.64, c0043) | reporting that Poland is trying to take the spot back | checking who held the flag's spot | T3-045 arguing who was there first | T4-014 Territoriality | D04 Order without law |
| "nobody is playing nice in /place, everybody just steps on you, why do we need permission from robots?" (r/snsd, cdy1YV6gNGWqIN4esPMzFqBfuJY=, h60.60, c0056) | rejecting permission because everybody steps on you in place | arguing over whose space to respect | T3-123 refusing to give up space | T4-014 Territoriality | D04 Order without law |
| "It seems like someone is building their blue and pink line right through our logo. Are we moving or just recovering it once it passes?" (r/twentyonepilots, 20qc5FR/lXBky0vfGDusYBBWXKA=, h30.02, c0042) | asking whether to move or recover after a line passes through the logo | moving, rebuilding, and stopping when the logo is covered | T3-124 weighing fighting against moving | T4-014 Territoriality | D04 Order without law |
| "I'm surprised I haven't seen any minecraft stuff on /r/place. I think we might be able to negotiate with /r/placestart to get an icon somewhere" (r/minecraft, dd+tBdE5a919eWCX5RurGBGivu4=, h62.19, c0215) | proposing negotiation with /r/placestart to get an icon somewhere | Negotiating room and alliances for Minecraft marks | T3-035 asking a host for space | T4-014 Territoriality | D04 Order without law |
| "The green lattice guys actively cover stuff up unless you get your art approved by them." (r/gameboy, dZD7UnSzC0nr6mCEua/yWXDaEHw=, h72.43, c0010) | warning that green lattice covers art not approved by them | warning that green lattice covers unapproved art | T3-094 disputing who approves a spot | T4-014 Territoriality | D04 Order without law |
| "I've been in contact with/r/france and they told me it's a smaller France sub trying to destroy all the artwork on the flag. They said they'd help us defend it but it's prollytoo late for that now" (r/vinesauce, MN0/0T/FMBmW3RW/NinuhqTEBxk=, h49.37, c0098) | relaying r/france's warning and late offer to defend | working things out with neighboring communities | T3-099 relying on a bigger neighbour | T4-014 Territoriality | D04 Order without law |
| "We will review all art and divide the area between those we've wronged in the past." (r/PlaceNL, NfAarM/8NlE8LloF316+y3OBmU8=, h66.22, c0081) | reviewing art and dividing area among groups previously wronged | assigning orange space to displaced groups | T3-162 vetting others' requests to build | T4-014 Territoriality | D04 Order without law |
| "lets not retaliate. LETS BUILD ANOTHER GODDAMN FLAG." (r/pakistan, pleOLW4gpbppR4ABPz6x/vXeAG8=, h50.85, c0135) | rejecting retaliation and calling for another flag | rejecting retaliation and calling for another flag | T3-007 urging repair over retaliation | T4-015 Live and let live | D04 Order without law |
| "DO NOT GREEN SOMEONES ART!" (r/TheGreatGreenBox, BfbaGNbYrrlkwZiQrYTsQdlU788=, h6.70, c0046) | telling greens not to destroy art | keeping pictures and signs out of the green sweep | T3-024 refusing to cover others' work | T4-015 Live and let live | D04 Order without law |
| "Good old battle of Alberta. Maybe add a VS in between?" (r/edmontonoilers, L7l8ZhDVDOa32e8iHXbbJym90zI=, h13.41, c0014) | proposing a Battle of Alberta VS between logos | keeping the Battle of Alberta on the canvas without a war | T3-025 placing rival marks together | T4-015 Live and let live | D04 Order without law |
| "Most of us have stopped, don't worry. I'll lend in a hand and give you one of my blocks to repair the harm done." (r/flyers, TyUaW+yOVAKON+tWnAK2OuQW9v4=, h53.91, c0148) | saying most stopped and offering a block to repair harm | working out space, repair, and help with neighbours | T3-040 apologizing to neighbours for damage | T4-015 Live and let live | D04 Order without law |
| "the spot should be for them." (r/FaroeIslands, VdDsJRZTYWzvG7RHz82oNwQg3Eo=, h70.97, c0053) | saying the Viking-ship spot should stay Finnish | arguing over taking, sharing and leaving other flags alone | T3-046 arguing whether covering is fair | T4-015 Live and let live | D04 Order without law |
| "Guys, I'm not going to lie, I've had some fun over here going back and forth and I just want to say thank you. However, this is kinda growing old in my opinion so I will be taking my leave." (r/ukplace, EIZ5QrP3vM4qHdQOC/zdUIQ0m74=, h88.52, c0079) | ending the argument after enjoying the back-and-forth | turning the row into banter and thanks | T3-047 making up with another sub | T4-015 Live and let live | D04 Order without law |
| "Stop, they have more people. Just stop trying to fight others." (r/osu, 4uy0LBsvCUQWHzcKIBB9gCgFocI=, h56.80, c0083) | answering a help call by telling people to stop fighting | stopping attacks and working out coexistence | T3-076 reining in the room's attackers | T4-015 Live and let live | D04 Order without law |
| "Nah I'm going to hit the bills with green" (r/nyjets, OpJRT0TF/VghdqM8nkbgZVwo6ds=, h58.02, c0164) | insisting on hitting the Bills after being told no | insisting on hitting the Bills after being told no | T3-102 defying the call for restraint | T4-015 Live and let live | D04 Order without law |
| "The more running the script the faster it goes" (r/Fez, AkNX2VggZnNlV6j6vlzIascomIc=, h70.44, c0079) | recruiting people to run the rebuild script | mourning Gomez and making amends afterward | T3-119 turning attackers into helpers | T4-015 Live and let live | D04 Order without law |
| "armenia and india overwrote squidward. why the hate?" (r/spongebob, G4hYkTsTEXcvlbwQJWPHqE3nsIk=, h61.37, c0024) | asking why armenia and india overwrote Squidward | watching threats and arguing over who covered whom | T3-139 pleading with attackers to stop | T4-015 Live and let live | D04 Order without law |
| "There was a mango on /r/place that we covered up to create more wavy art" (r/kanye, 9OQQ20CwAudjZbqyPeR29mxp95E=, h46.25, c0259) | admitting they covered the mango to make wavy art | mourning pictures the Wave displaced | T3-183 mourning art the room covered | T4-015 Live and let live | D04 Order without law |
| "Are they doing anything under the text? Otherwise, this only covers 2 letter pixels." (r/satania, DuChduecSHv2Zv/CjaNJpoL8i74=, h40.65, c0081) | measuring the overlap as two letter pixels | asking neighbours before covering their work | T3-010 settling borders with neighbours | T4-016 Negotiated order | D04 Order without law |
| "Red will turn on you again. You have been warned." (r/GreenCorner, JKtBslg3w8HSPz/6eW1XKoGNUk0=, h9.04, c0092) | warning that Red will betray Green again | warning that Red will betray Green again | T3-030 disputing how an alliance went | T4-016 Negotiated order | D04 Order without law |
| "Go after that Zootopia. It is taking up way more space than we are and we will help you out if you wish in return to let us have our space and help us protect it." (r/thailand, PXz4x+Ujeob9AEyQONkxMpQ6IHU=, h60.53, c0165) | redirecting attack toward Zootopia and offering reciprocal protection | bargaining for space and trading help with neighbours | T3-067 trading away another room's work | T4-016 Negotiated order | D04 Order without law |
| "you did... call them and ask for forgiveness" (r/portugal, NYtVrWcNf0JVc2rqeChrfyjGITw=, h42.50, c0124) | joking that the ally should ask former teachers for forgiveness | making alliances and doing diplomacy | T3-083 negotiating across a language gap | T4-016 Negotiated order | D04 Order without law |
| "nhxzUbHSB2U2MU7bWahUhFtJMpM= don't listen to that idiot. He's not representing /r/Turkey there is no declaration of war against you." (r/Homura, byNmI95fIV+oIRNTDkuRbc1KZs8=, h68.89, c0020) | telling Homura not to listen and denying any declaration of war | rejecting the claim that r/Turkey declared war | T3-126 disputing who speaks for rooms | T4-016 Negotiated order | D04 Order without law |
| "Guess we’d better stay neutral, then." (r/placeportalpattern, o7PmHmmcJqNKdPMteOT/ZiHcL4k=, h71.19, c0115) | deciding to stay neutral between friendly sides | asking for and returning help across neighboring groups | T3-138 staying neutral between two rooms | T4-016 Negotiated order | D04 Order without law |
| "Ho proposto una tregua ai comunisti, magari ci alleiamo per difenderci a vicenda." (r/theitalyplace, DcrL7f5lStRV8i7OK8LzN2wxB4s=, h47.64, c0061) | proposing a truce and mutual defense with the communists | making peace around neighbouring pictures | T3-149 agreeing truces with rival rooms | T4-016 Negotiated order | D04 Order without law |
| (no concept is cited under this theme) |  |  | T3-161 mediating between other rooms | T4-016 Negotiated order | D04 Order without law |
| "i'd rather see our work destroyed than team up with the cowboys, giants or skins. fuck em" (r/eagles, pxm76iN4FOhIZs5Druy8xT4y5Gg=, h70.30, c0210) | preferring their work destroyed to teaming with division rivals | weighing a peace treaty with division rivals | T3-193 arguing whether cooperation is surrender | T4-016 Negotiated order | D04 Order without law |
| "Today, I became a diplomat for the Day Knights." (r/day9, [deleted], h54.98, c0033) | becoming a diplomat for the Day Knights | making pixel-border deals with neighbours | T3-194 acting as envoys between rooms | T4-016 Negotiated order | D04 Order without law |
| "Are we just taking them over now, I thought we had an established border" (r/weezer, qC0OPVWpetRfs1zDcuHLmSFlklg=, h47.44, c0064) | questioning a takeover because an established border existed | making, breaching, and repairing border deals | T3-195 holding rooms to their agreements | T4-016 Negotiated order | D04 Order without law |
| "I will donate some pixels, hoodr is finished for now." (r/epublica, 0LOm6BwmDSPUFF7SgpvRx2EjmMA=, h66.51, c0080) | donating Hoodr pixels to help finish epublica's work | helping Hoodr and accepting Hoodr's help | T3-011 helping another room's work | T4-017 Reciprocity | D04 Order without law |
| "The Irish have adopted your triangle character dude. He will be spared." (r/nuclearthrone, hFeBO+NxhDBb6oatQ1IfVaz8Ep0=, h50.13, c0058) | reporting that Ireland adopted and will spare Y.V. | making room with Ireland | T3-071 letting neighbours adopt the work | T4-017 Reciprocity | D04 Order without law |
| "It's an honour, big thanks to r/Ireland for allowing Temmie!" (r/undertale, f+uZkH9zxBqAXyQvSodd78lukhQ=, h47.60, c0204) | thanking r/Ireland for allowing Temmie | thanking allies and telling the alliance story | T3-072 thanking the room's allies | T4-017 Reciprocity | D04 Order without law |
| "FH, CC, RWBY, and RVB are all pretty safe from vandalism at this point.  If we had a template (that fits into the current space), maybe those subs could help us." (r/roosterteeth, iNR8u4RusSQC1MB67az1YnUwwvE=, h58.11, c0179) | asking safe sister subs to help from a fitting template | working around neighbours and asking allies for help | T3-084 asking other rooms for help | T4-017 Reciprocity | D04 Order without law |
| "And eliminating national flags at hearts? Piss off" (r/seolhyun, PXLQaPpf88G2RA24o3r+NRgvUgU=, h64.30, c0035) | telling the WJSN group to piss off for eliminating flags at hearts | asking for help with nearby small logos | T3-115 turning away another room's request | T4-017 Reciprocity | D04 Order without law |
| "GT student here, glad to be a neighbor with y'all" (r/iastate, YqFnIW9+9Y20SfGdl8o/fX49yO4=, h70.47, c0057) | greeting ISU as a neighboring GT student | making room with canvas neighbors and split loyalties | T3-122 sending greetings to another room | T4-017 Reciprocity | D04 Order without law |
| "We will not destroy the UF symbol, but rather expand the white and help defend your symbol." (r/floridagators, 44N3elGsFbpALhWOCsJEx9TbbsU=, h54.01, c0077) | offering not to destroy UF and to expand white and defend it | making treaties and trading spare clicks with neighbors | T3-151 bartering help with neighbours | T4-017 Reciprocity | D04 Order without law |
| "Hey guys, check out /r/CFBplace for this sorta stuff!" (r/sooners, RUHQeEXO51X2Gtqxj/RQSo6kLAo=, h56.09, c0008) | sending this sorta stuff to r/CFBplace | sending logo work to r/CFBplace | T3-013 gathering kindred rooms together | T4-018 Meta-organization | D04 Order without law |
| "IIRC, UF was there too before the Windows 95 start button took over" (r/ucf, /+rRO27PAvPcedJ6rjF8wffBKbs=, h48.58, c0012) | recalling the start button taking over UF | putting UCF with the other colleges | T3-019 tallying kindred rooms' works | T4-018 Meta-organization | D04 Order without law |
| "Big 10 Logo lets do this together - /r/place" (r/rutgers, f8sbGSusSAE2rkADRIowEyMTjTc=, h37.74, c0063) | calling the Big 10 to make a logo together on r/place | trading help and protection with other schools | T3-056 making joint marks with others | T4-018 Meta-organization | D04 Order without law |
| "/r/Funhaus and /r/Naruto should stick together." (r/naruto, 4gTjxx+D3bI+dALQzVlw+Z3n2lM=, h70.73, c0168) | saying Funhaus and Naruto should stick together | making alliances and working around neighbours | T3-150 forming alliances between rooms | T4-018 Meta-organization | D04 Order without law |
| "Join us in our discord, we're willing to help" (r/duckgame, j1vyu8ClQtCmsEBAwowEFBqY3/Q=, h34.94, c0019) | inviting duckgame into Mexico's Discord to help | making a sombrero deal with Mexico | T3-153 meeting other rooms in chat | T4-018 Meta-organization | D04 Order without law |
| "Didn't I tell you to stop makin up animals!" (r/Pigifs, JBpsa7bO/dJV+4dAPLmPF1G4qsA=, h21.92, c0010) | telling someone to stop making up animals | making warthogs into fighting machines and Halo jokes | T3-031 playing the room's in-jokes | T4-004 Frame bridging | D05 Collective identity |
| "My last pixel was used to fix flaggy flag. PRIORITIES." (r/cgpgrey, nL6PL4R6iiQq+ttAmIF9/PXzcPk=, h73.14, c0036) | using the last pixel to fix flaggy flag | choosing between HI, flags, and other factions | T3-086 carrying in the sub's quarrel | T4-004 Frame bridging | D05 Collective identity |
| "It's basically a giant game of Splatoon, you should all be dominating" (r/splatoon, zs2NMhVRxODf9mjkqyhn3KpNnz8=, h26.21, c0034) | telling Splatoon members to dominate the giant game | making r/place sound like Splatoon | T3-135 telling clashes as fandom lore | T4-004 Frame bridging | D05 Collective identity |
| "It proves that people can cooperate and organize even with a lack of a central, regulatory, intrusive agency." (r/anarcho_capitalism, [deleted], h75.59, c0167) | treating cooperation as proof people can organize without a central agency | reading politics and property into the canvas | T3-179 arguing ideology from the canvas | T4-004 Frame bridging | D05 Collective identity |
| "that is a prime location for you guys and we icelanders will mos def give you a helping hand" (r/FaroeIslands, sl/s41ttIrygNlfBd8aOB7pc2II=, h52.28, c0015) | offering Icelandic help at a prime location | joining in to build, fix and defend the flags | T3-078 helping kin nations' flags | T4-022 Flagging the nation | D05 Collective identity |
| "Can we please turn our heart flag upside down?" (r/czech, 3nVdpr/wXhPxS7cJ2404BAXCuOc=, h71.07, c0268) | asking to turn the heart flag upside down | putting beer, hearts, words and Czech pictures on the canvas | T3-079 joining flags with a heart | T4-022 Flagging the nation | D05 Collective identity |
| "Zweer trouw aan uw nieuwe Koninkrijk!" (r/armenia, YLf1og7pnPdhEDPukh1MNyBwh08=, h45.83, c0102) | demanding loyalty to a new kingdom | fighting and narrating flag takeovers | T3-081 casting fights as national history | T4-022 Flagging the nation | D05 Collective identity |
| "to me they both equally have no value r/theblackvoid" (r/diablo, h0r0e7k4Rw/wjvLcnY6aabnkeS8=, h71.04, c0034) | saying Diablo and the flag have equal lack of value | arguing over replacing Mexico's flag | T3-085 weighing the room against nations | T4-022 Flagging the nation | D05 Collective identity |
| "Let's Celebrate our BASED President - He would be VERY proud of the flag!" (r/afip, 3XCbKWuR4k4azy8RwpjHDrk+4g0=, h37.47, c0008) | proposing to celebrate the president through the flag | keeping party claims off the flag | T3-130 reading national politics in pixels | T4-022 Flagging the nation | D05 Collective identity |
| "FUCK YOU NIGGERS FOR GETTING RID OF THE AVATAR HEAD ON /R/place!!!!" (r/catalunya, UBJ7/trttb5S85rg/I6xEmFbZl8=, h79.03, c0067) | abusing the community for removing the Avatar head | settling the Avatar fight with abuse | T3-142 making ethnic jokes about rivals | T4-022 Flagging the nation | D05 Collective identity |
| "mi senta più italiano in un giochino/esperimento sociale che nelle situazioni quotidiane" (r/theitalyplace, YQ3Hep+l4A3EMqHKAZXumqcBLqg=, h73.65, c0311) | feeling more Italian in the game than in daily life | telling what the finished canvas meant and might have been | T3-145 feeling national through the canvas | T4-022 Flagging the nation | D05 Collective identity |
| "Arrange Palestine flag next to Israeli on Place?" (r/palestine, yU+gbxlMyZVYhYLicGBpdCVEAvE=, h69.65, c0033) | proposing adjacent Palestinian and Israeli flags | arguing whether Palestine and Israel should sit side by side | T3-165 debating friendship with historic enemies | T4-022 Flagging the nation | D05 Collective identity |
| "So i guess we are like the americans when they invade other countries and support dictatorships. We are always right and fight for freedom." (r/greece, JW35CrEORyHflbHchcLoXc+B9M4=, h79.74, c0175) | mocking the claim that a nation is always right | arguing whether Greeks are always on the right side of history | T3-166 arguing the nation's historical record | T4-022 Flagging the nation | D05 Collective identity |
| "Yes it is totally wrong. French speaking Quebecers are a distinct culture who deserve to have their emblems and symbols." (r/quebec, nHdU+7Xy0J/2314Un2qbfo5Px1U=, h74.59, c0111) | agreeing the overwrite was wrong and Quebecers deserve their symbols | turning the pixel fight into Québec history and identity | T3-180 disputing national belonging | T4-022 Flagging the nation | D05 Collective identity |
| "THE VOID WILL LIVE ON." (r/thesimpsons, e0QgUg1S98ppDelrD/gsE9O7zko=, h34.62, c0023) | answering the Homer defense call that THE VOID WILL LIVE ON | cheering THE VOID against Homer | T3-096 hailing the colour corners | T4-023 Neo-tribes | D05 Collective identity |
| "All my pixels are dedicated to the upkeep of r/PrequelMemes territory, sorry cives." (r/latin, Gy12QQQhR8dnmz2LzEvXZJbF4Cg=, h54.07, c0009) | declining because all pixels are keeping up PrequelMemes territory | putting all pixels into PrequelMemes instead | T3-137 joining an outside group's build | T4-023 Neo-tribes | D05 Collective identity |
| "I have realized my sin and am repenting." (r/greenlattice, a+P/Wrxel0qJJXOGKAAj7xZV7HA=, h29.11, c0315) | repenting after graffitiing the lattice | joining and preaching the lattice | T3-163 defecting from a rival faction | T4-023 Neo-tribes | D05 Collective identity |
| "We prey on and cleanse the weak, then we move on." (r/theblackvoid, GYZ3ObSSdveEEG/iIbwrA8ibVl8=, h67.86, c1553) | saying the Void cleanses the weak and moves on | Exploiting weak, dark, or undefended ground | T3-171 spreading a faction's colour | T4-023 Neo-tribes | D05 Collective identity |
| "We need to keep our unity strong, wherever this war takes us." (r/PinkUnion, n5aHNjanhmnw48LKuRTn0eFTG28=, h6.55, c0008) | keeping unity strong wherever the war goes | rallying Pinks to hold, grow, and recruit | T3-174 professing loyalty to a colour | T4-023 Neo-tribes | D05 Collective identity |
| "The lattice is majority white. This makes it not purple." (r/purplecorner, aVl0llZ3RObmhxLBcqmeqOunids=, h50.00, c0102) | rejecting the lattice as majority white | arguing over who speaks for purple | T3-190 splitting a faction over doctrine | T4-023 Neo-tribes | D05 Collective identity |
| "What the fuck?  Where did this idea come from, and why is it getting upvoted?" (r/partyparrot, owGXbFV+y1gjXQfKOA3TcGctzkg=, h74.24, c0112) | challenging where the communist idea came from | arguing whether communist party parrot is a joke or politics | T3-080 arguing over political symbols | T4-024 Symbolic boundaries | D05 Collective identity |
| "our sub loves PR so we decided to have a little bit of fun with it" (r/porterrobinson, 3lvuOGtepdJI6YT2Y8wvgGaXgYY=, h21.92, c0026) | explaining the joke as having fun with a PR-loving sub | arguing over the Worlds circlejerk April Fools layout | T3-143 judging whether a joke offends | T4-024 Symbolic boundaries | D05 Collective identity |
| "Please help bottom row overwrite the hateful message" (r/placehearts, KH15m4DioAtUcvy53rj5AENa5CI=, h21.37, c0057) | asking the bottom row to overwrite a hateful message | turning hateful or empty pixels into love | T3-146 covering swastikas and hate symbols | T4-024 Symbolic boundaries | D05 Collective identity |
| "LET'S MAKE A SWASTIKA OVER ON R/PLACE" (r/dankmemes, [deleted], h50.66, c0561) | calling for making a swastika on r/place | Raiding and taking spots on the canvas | T3-177 calling to draw swastikas | T4-024 Symbolic boundaries | D05 Collective identity |
| "you are the reason the suicide rate is so high for trans people." (r/ultrahardcore, yPO8AIuXsoGwzPcGC/bdDaoC9rM=, h34.63, c0180) | holding the poster responsible for harm to trans people | using the day to post offensive and taboo material | T3-182 shutting down bigotry in chat | T4-024 Symbolic boundaries | D05 Collective identity |
| "Haha, happy April fool's day!" (r/Madeon, HZMjep3L6+QKqPncGizcwKC/55M=, h31.63, c0011) | answering the call-out with happy April fool's day | playing out a fake album leak together | T3-001 staging April Fools fake news | T4-001 Keying | D06 Host framing |
| "Well played mod, well played" (r/snsd, RhDQAA1fIRwSqBMWqQa/0mlJCn4=, h15.71, c0007) | telling the mod the sidebar trick was well played | playing along with and ending the SinB sidebar trick | T3-023 running an April Fools takeover | T4-001 Keying | D06 Host framing |
| "Thank god the subreddit isn't being spammed with recorded rounds anymore" (r/ultrahardcore, [deleted], h22.95, c0128) | mock-thanking the end of recorded-round spam while adding a post | arguing over what counts as a good joke or post | T3-032 objecting to April Fools posts | T4-001 Keying | D06 Host framing |
| "Yep! The basic cloud sprite seems to be replaced with tasty chickens. All seething and roiling weirdly." (r/feedthebeast, sHZH+y8k5bYwlPxg91Cn5ysBMrg=, h48.65, c0059) | identifying tasty chickens replacing the cloud sprite | making, sharing, and extending mod-themed April Fools jokes | T3-048 reacting to official April Fools | T4-001 Keying | D06 Host framing |
| "You should have seen r/diepio." (r/mariokart, lNZDbIs38PsWC/LfsTlU+tDZk1Y=, h33.70, c0011) | pointing to r/diepio as another subreddit joke to see | pointing to another subreddit takeover joke | T3-064 spreading the room's joke elsewhere | T4-001 Keying | D06 Host framing |
| "Pretty sure I've said multiple times if I was ever a mod I'd sticky every post until they kicked me off the team." (r/seahawks, 1GR0XlVsK+4VwiGmAsNixOh9jg0=, h13.01, c0020) | planning to sticky every post until being kicked off the team | playing with moderator powers | T3-093 playing with granted moderator powers | T4-001 Keying | D06 Host framing |
| "Serious Question: Did we get hacked or Did they botch the april fools prank and deploy too early?" (r/detroitlions, [deleted], h5.72, c0018) | asking whether the April Fools prank deployed early | working out whether the Titans takeover is a joke | T3-095 testing others' April Fools claims | T4-001 Keying | D06 Host framing |
| "With new tab on the left on r/dtg, some of the layers of text are overlapping in the thread section" (r/DestinyTheGame, 2QgV5wYb+u+RKQ4vPBI3o7LH5To=, h28.58, c0137) | reporting overlapping text after the new left tab | swapping the subreddit look and joking through the breakage | T3-097 switching off the prank styling | T4-001 Keying | D06 Host framing |
| "megane flairs available all-year round" (r/starlightstage, r0T+hU43/yAvX6RMWRfhfvI68ko=, h63.70, c0075) | working to keep the megane flairs all year | asking to keep or extend the Megane changes | T3-100 keeping April Fools changes afterwards | T4-001 Keying | D06 Host framing |
| "my saltiness means I'm going to pirate for a little while." (r/samuraijack, s6YpXzTZiK7TL4wHTILBwiI3B0E=, h38.48, c0140) | answering the prank by planning to pirate | threatening to withhold views over the switch | T3-106 calling a network boycott | T4-001 Keying | D06 Host framing |
| "Make another post and stick that to the top of the sub with the discord link and all the info and goals. I'll make you one of the admins in the discord server if you respond quick" (r/bangladesh, AtseVBu48BJq0g9p3e8S3Gnydjo=, h68.39, c0029) | asking for a stickied post that carries Discord, information and goals | asking someone to organize and moving raids to Discord | T3-015 routing canvas posts into megathreads | T4-002 Boundary work | D06 Host framing |
| "What the fuck are you slevvering about?" (r/glasgow, f+gPfDy6O0ScW35WJuzMzW7E33Y=, h6.25, c0002) | asking what the saltire organiser is slevvering about | asking what the saltire talk is about | T3-037 arguing the canvas's worth | T4-002 Boundary work | D06 Host framing |
| "removing shit on a pretty constant basis" (r/thailand, ZenxJx9xosMM2Z75cORIrjgtEpI=, h65.00, c0079) | moderators removing uncivil r/place material and warning of bans | concentrating r/place talk and policing the fight | T3-063 removing canvas posts by rule | T4-002 Boundary work | D06 Host framing |
| "i made a new subreddit for all you fuckheads posting about r/place GTFO" (r/frankocean, [deleted], h71.03, c0171) | creating a new subreddit to push place posters out | arguing about whether r/place belongs in the room | T3-075 objecting to the canvas flood | T4-002 Boundary work | D06 Host framing |
| "Sure it is, we're in /r/armok. Two of the three posts in here are stickies directing people to /r/DwarfFortress." (r/armok, 3gj2hAq/JYUy8E6tW32VA9GI70E=, h37.70, c0010) | defending r/armok as a redirect to r/DwarfFortress | making r/armok easy to find and use for coordination | T3-090 opening a canvas sub | T4-002 Boundary work | D06 Host framing |
| (no concept is cited under this theme) |  |  | T3-140 moderators disowning the canvas work | T4-002 Boundary work | D06 Host framing |
| "Gotta help out /r/place stay loopy" (r/kanye, kCSsz0GpqRIEVUkVKm9n8lyV8uw=, h53.03, c0313) | holding off Graduation Survivor to help r/place stay loopy | putting Survivor on hold for r/place | T3-184 pausing the sub's usual events | T4-002 Boundary work | D06 Host framing |
| "Allow 1 Game like post a day. I know these threads might have the lowest quality of discussion, but I am also not against having fun, especially if they can serve as an icebreaker for lurkers and the community" (r/indieheads, XpZbBfsDR7CL4rAQ1Oh3E654tRY=, h24.11, c0040) | proposing one game post a day as a fun icebreaker | arguing whether loose weekend posting welcomes people or makes the sub look bad | T3-185 changing the sub's posting rules | T4-002 Boundary work | D06 Host framing |
| "Did not know about r/sheffield until I was looking at Saitama and thought 'does- does that say Sheffield?'" (r/sheffield, OsVOb9GNPcFufAO8aja5UKfdVIY=, h93.24, c0061) | discovering r/sheffield through Sheffield beside Saitama | putting and finding Sheffield on place | T3-044 recruiting canvas visitors | T4-025 Visibility returns | D07 Imprinting |
| "Best Music Video. Upvote this so when people Google 'Best Music Video' this is what they'll see." (r/rush, [deleted], h29.50, c0071) | duplicating the Best Music Video upvote format | pushing Best Music Video with copies and repetition | T3-051 pushing posts up the rankings | T4-025 Visibility returns | D07 Imprinting |
| "Lets arrange the posts to say something retarded on the front page" (r/hearthstone, nLBp3UlkgetymSS1lO861MjWg4M=, h15.26, c0070) | proposing arranging the posts on the front page | building SpongeBob chants across posts and replies | T3-053 spelling slogans with post titles | T4-025 Visibility returns | D07 Imprinting |
| "J'irais mettre un pixel sur r/place pour vous remercier." (r/france, exANsbsmRuvpOSVtYr2uNm6Toec=, h51.18, c0394) | promising an r/place pixel as thanks for help | trading ordinary help for a thank-you pixel | T3-110 placing a tile as payment | T4-025 Visibility returns | D07 Imprinting |
| "That would be pretty dope" (r/gameattack, 20Ep8f3oV7QyPT641eWoEGpexl8=, h58.56, c0041) | agreeing a podcast mention would be dope | hoping the crew talks about the logo | T3-127 seeking the creators' notice | T4-025 Visibility returns | D07 Imprinting |
| "where should we attempt again" (r/TransFlagPlace, DWHkApM2+G+Je97d/6M3ynQwYto=, h58.61, c0229) | asking where to attempt Black Lives Matter again | adding words, hearts, and other marks to the flag | T3-129 making passers-by notice a demand | T4-025 Visibility returns | D07 Imprinting |
| "[rbtv jetzt auch unter den Top-Ergebnissen bei Google!](https://www.google.de/?gws_rd=ssl#q=rbtv&*)" (r/rocketbeans, gShMERVKQF2GfwEvqVt/SWLAQDo=, h86.80, c0155) | mocking the viral claim with a Google-results joke | claiming and mocking attention from the taskbar | T3-147 sharing the work's press coverage | T4-025 Visibility returns | D07 Imprinting |
| "yeah It would likely force them to halt all new articles entirely." (r/scp, CZkMVxjw4s4SOy0q5gbqXOT4XS4=, h55.37, c0108) | predicting exposure would force a halt to new articles | weighing who the canvas brings into SCP | T3-189 fearing newcomers the mark draws | T4-025 Visibility returns | D07 Imprinting |
| "com a mínim hem activat una mica el subreddit" (r/catalunya, /Eq98g6pRF38mzeXoz6a3y//QD8=, h75.17, c0064) | crediting r/place with activating the subreddit | crediting r/place with waking up the subreddit | T3-196 drawing lapsed fans back | T4-025 Visibility returns | D07 Imprinting |
| "I'm helping from Australia, thanks for having me for 12 months Sheffield!" (r/sheffield, DvAeXN77SzoWcybNCciHgoeHdGA=, h63.71, c0012) | helping from Australia to thank Sheffield for having them | helping Sheffield from away | T3-003 reporting one's own placing labour | T4-026 Completion ritual | D07 Imprinting |
| "if we can at least have it up for a second i'll feel like I have spent my time productively" (r/pitt, W5lyngHaQwN7A2xkvLE8wkLfQq0=, h33.75, c0025) | counting one visible second as productive | celebrating what Pitt made | T3-009 celebrating the finished work | T4-026 Completion ritual | D07 Imprinting |
| "i couldn't fucking find it anywhere on /r/place. did it get destroyed?" (r/furry_irl, iuQjj3v1lhts/RVfeSWY4Dqnhqc=, h78.69, c0140) | asking whether the missing drawing was destroyed | helping people find the finished drawing | T3-026 announcing the mark is up | T4-026 Completion ritual | D07 Imprinting |
| "thanks everyone for their work, defense what we have. Notes about defending allies are also on the Discord." (r/pathofexile, PwOQedU18LHW11nyLA5yG4CSM1A=, h70.13, c0111) | thanking painters and telling them to defend the work and allies | celebrating, thanking, and mourning the shared work | T3-043 crediting who made the work | T4-026 Completion ritual | D07 Imprinting |
| "don't ever forget the valiant effort of our union!" (r/PinkUnion, n5aHNjanhmnw48LKuRTn0eFTG28=, h75.20, c0073) | asking the union not to forget its effort | marking, explaining, and remembering what happened | T3-157 reflecting on working together | T4-026 Completion ritual | D07 Imprinting |
| "voy a sortear una versión impresa de nuestro trabajo entre las personas que han ayudado en nuestra bandera en r/place" (r/chile, aH7LBaPho+8n2IU+f6JIFfVBSTU=, h57.32, c0094) | offering a print of their work to flag helpers | saving and rewarding people's r/place work | T3-159 rewarding helpers with prizes | T4-026 Completion ritual | D07 Imprinting |
| "sometimes it seems that the world is going backwards but then public projects like this prove that idea wrong." (r/traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns, ZQ1osfsZgS0BsDLHXiCK57EOOz4=, h21.00, c0060) | taking the public project as proof the world is not going backwards | taking the flag as proof of support and not being alone | T3-164 feeling supported through the canvas | T4-026 Completion ritual | D07 Imprinting |
| "If anyone would like to go out for dinner/beer or BBQ you should message me! It would be great to celebrate this feat in Person!" (r/SwissNeutralityZone, CmRHDyrELXb/MgCTgE89yIkAjdM=, h95.54, c0108) | inviting people to celebrate the feat in person | inviting people to celebrate the feat in person | T3-186 celebrating the feat in person | T4-026 Completion ritual | D07 Imprinting |
| "I don't usually feel proud about Columbia but even just this attempt gives me something to believe in." (r/columbia, NnflaWKGOGeq+a8wnzE9IbjSFUg=, h83.50, c0046) | finding unusual Columbia pride in the attempt | remembering the attempt after the canvas closed | T3-029 mourning the lost work | T4-027 Collective memory | D07 Imprinting |
| "[Here it is! To the left side.](http://i.imgur.com/twU55EF.png)" (r/k_on, scGBSTt/Q5G4Uf9ciQf+7Uhx1xA=, h79.58, c0026) | pointing out the logo on the final canvas | checking what survived and finding it on the final canvas | T3-073 reporting how the work fared | T4-027 Collective memory | D07 Imprinting |
| "Someone has created a /r/Place timelapse video (36 hours plus)" (r/placehearts, +ZT7SzMOGppLW3njl7CY5qRqDUw=, h49.58, c0235) | posting to the heart placers: Someone has created a /r/Place timelapse video (36 hours plus) | keeping and sharing a record of the canvas | T3-105 saving screenshots and timelapses | T4-027 Collective memory | D07 Imprinting |
| "Can some of you please mark it and put a nicely worded text in the about box? Thanks!" (r/warframe, safBl35FabPQMcDV4vKh/Ufy8o0=, h81.03, c0285) | asking members to mark the logo and write its about-box text | writing the icon into the atlas and crediting GreenLattice | T3-112 entering the work in atlases | T4-027 Collective memory | D07 Imprinting |
| "It's over! Shame, a few hours earlier and it'd be pretty untouched. Rip Vocaloid logo, rip miku's skirt, but not bad I guess." (r/hatsune, 8vPJH7VxHc93bVIEoQWfpnSQ1Kg=, h73.44, c0054) | mourning damage while judging the finished result not bad | saying it is over and leaving a smol mark | T3-117 marking the canvas's end | T4-027 Collective memory | D07 Imprinting |
| "They never responded to us after we came to an agreement, I think they just gave up :/" (r/ssbpm, dZH61gOOv8neesnisXiZL6muvcE=, h79.31, c0143) | saying agreed partners stopped responding and apparently gave up | mourning the additions they could not finish | T3-148 imagining art the canvas missed | T4-027 Collective memory | D07 Imprinting |
| "Jaaa, want met pixels spelen is leuk! <3" (r/aeskwadraat, P1/g1LhGBNgxBhhphYU7LIN2vr4=, h76.14, c0011) | backing the idea because playing with pixels is fun | trying to keep playing with pixels on a smaller local place | T3-054 carrying work to new canvases | T4-028 Transition | D07 Imprinting |
| "After Place and our success, I thought it'd be cool to do pixel art for every album." (r/coldplay, hyIbykzBZsJQyYKdXxfvjvAjLf8=, h78.42, c0076) | turning r/place success into pixel art for every album | making pixel art for every album after Place | T3-057 remaking canvas art elsewhere | T4-028 Transition | D07 Imprinting |
| "Is the discord only for r/place?" (r/scp, Mxi/HM+TQRUlJz6kZCEP0rubrpc=, h74.30, c0137) | asking whether the Discord is only for r/place | moving the location decision and later chat into Discord | T3-111 repurposing the canvas sub | T4-028 Transition | D07 Imprinting |
| "$3 *off*? How hard are you raping /r/kanye for a shitty poster that costs less than that to make?" (r/kanye, RAdd5+syyaBCF+EOiGoc9F0yqGk=, h86.88, c0431) | accusing the poster seller of overcharging r/kanye | arguing over selling the room's shared work | T3-131 arguing over selling canvas art | T4-028 Transition | D07 Imprinting |
| "Just change the logo to match this? It'll be our secret" (r/corridor, cdSmx47tvFqYWcS+sNi6+Aws3YM=, h74.98, c0041) | joking about changing the community logo to match the pixels | joking about making the pixel version their secret logo | T3-156 adopting the mark as emblem | T4-028 Transition | D07 Imprinting |
| "Sounds good. I'll look into it tonight :) (along with the discord stuff)" (r/wales, 6tMJtpFpYoaP1HenUlIbrpD7lmg=, h90.17, c0056) | agreeing as moderator to look into the sidebar and Discord | carrying the Faroe alliance beyond the canvas | T3-158 proposing ties beyond the canvas | T4-028 Transition | D07 Imprinting |
| "I adding a pink battlefront to the left side of the tree next to the US flag if anyone wants to join!!!" (r/PinkUnion, QP96ZekDV8ms2NC5LuCYch18ZRU=, h59.76, c0071) | inviting others to a pink battlefront by the US flag | taking coalition fights beyond the home triangle | T3-006 calling to deface rivals' work | T4-020 Repertoire of contention | D08 Contention |
| "Yeah, our flag is lost. Let's take 403, 55." (r/poland, LaHACiomNYx9mblFiReEOaoMrU4=, h23.77, c0020) | declaring the flag lost and naming a new target | starting and extending Polish pictures | T3-061 pushing into a neighbour's space | T4-020 Repertoire of contention | D08 Contention |
| "I'm not Turkish, but does anyone here want to turn the communist hammer and sickle on /r/place into the star and crescent?" (r/turkey, [deleted], h72.12, c0222) | asking to turn the r/place hammer and sickle into a star and crescent | proposing words, ornaments, and other marks beyond the standard flag | T3-068 converting a neighbour's art | T4-020 Repertoire of contention | D08 Contention |
| "Call To Arms from Tyler1" (r/ice_poseidon, j5BlMZI+hVtTqINlc46Q1ck+HeQ=, h36.37, c0171) | relaying Tyler1's call to arms | Answering Tyler1’s call to black out osu | T3-128 relaying a streamer's attack call | T4-020 Repertoire of contention | D08 Contention |
| "I'm like 10% of those posts lol. I'm pretty proud of that psyop." (r/completeanarchy, nkpe5dfZ0uZCkCC77J7nkw5hFVU=, h85.42, c0298) | claiming ten percent of the posts and pride in the psyop | retelling the weekend fight and script trick | T3-176 planting disguised scripts on rivals | T4-020 Repertoire of contention | D08 Contention |
| "Abort mission i repeat abort mission. Let people enjoy what they want." (r/dankmemes, eDiE+2m2DPUPCxDMq0nXKRxq0nk=, h50.80, c0505) | calling to abort the mission and let people enjoy things | Raiding one Instagram normie after the fiasco | T3-178 brigading one person off Reddit | T4-020 Repertoire of contention | D08 Contention |
| "I'm in. I recently added a red color pixel to the Habs logo." (r/penguins, HmSj+LUgMEFgIAj3MIMZb1X9mIo=, h30.95, c0015) | adding a red pixel to the Habs logo before joining the Pens effort | adding a red pixel to the Habs before joining the Pens | T3-192 griefing the work for fun | T4-020 Repertoire of contention | D08 Contention |
| "We did it with the power of friendship" (r/seolhyun, biMKE4aJ2CPyawFjZTdx/2JrJpw=, h48.80, c0017) | crediting the power of friendship | arguing over wiping out and stealing the Jets logo | T3-050 trading taunts with rivals | T4-021 Rivalry | D08 Contention |
| "¡Muerte al cruasán! ¡Los franchutes nos arrebataron nuestra esquina! ¡Exijo **venganza**!" (r/spain, msYs+x3Av0Bv2NPZ5EdZcm+/ab0=, h73.31, c0073) | demanding vengeance after the French took their corner | cursing, blaming and mocking the croissant attack | T3-058 blaming attackers after the close | T4-021 Rivalry | D08 Contention |
| "Wilhelmus van Nassouwe - Netherlands National Anthem" (r/armenia, ndyBBrHPNuxOZaEmzFgGTasMW5g=, h45.88, c0105) | posting the Netherlands national anthem during the takeover | fighting and narrating flag takeovers | T3-134 flooding rivals' threads with chants | T4-021 Rivalry | D08 Contention |
| "Looks like /r/place has finally ended.  It was fun while it lasted, and [/r/anarchism almost took over](https://gfycat.com/InfamousShyEeve) last night!" (r/anarchism, eS2uMCzcGtrw3k+dBguAQHy40ss=, h71.56, c0114) | saying r/anarchism almost took over before place ended | claiming victory and left unity after place ended | T3-154 claiming victory over rival rooms | T4-021 Rivalry | D08 Contention |
| "I THINK /R/THE_FACK DESERVES TO BE CONGRATULATED FOR THEIR EFFORTS" (r/the_pack, lm52liFzc8CSACTVVYfoptbGTwI=, h90.77, c0112) | proposing that THE_FACK be congratulated for its efforts | deciding how to answer THE_FACK | T3-155 saluting rivals after the fight | T4-021 Rivalry | D08 Contention |

## The residue

Two third-order themes no fourth-order theme picked up. Each comes with its account from the foot of `fourth/fourth.md` and one quote by the same rule. Every fourth-order theme sits in a dimension, so no fourth-order theme is residue.

- **T3-017 carrying on ordinary sub talk (334, 212). The sub's ordinary business going on during the canvas week, apart from the canvas and April Fools. It is the ground the host community's boundary work protects, not an act of organizing the work, and no story about the canvas holds it.**
  - "it's not a shitty spek is it? Looks pretty even to me" (r/Madeon, 184/axNOLNZMotV34SMo6IDY2a4=, h58.44, c0029)
- **T3-133 recovering a hacked sub, rare (1, 1). A sub recovered after a moderator's account was hacked: one room, one event, unrelated to the canvas work.**
  - "A brand new mod got hacked, it's sorted now :)" (r/PUBATTLEGROUNDS, oXEjWwOhiyUQUdCxEsCXXg3ONUo=, h33.03, c0024)

## Dimensions and fourth-order themes, for the record

- **D01 Critical mass:** T4-003 Sensemaking; T4-005 Mobilization; T4-012 Collective efficacy.
- **D02 Coordination without command:** T4-006 Collective representation; T4-007 Direct information sharing; T4-008 Standardization of output; T4-009 Workarounds; T4-010 Backstage decision-making; T4-011 Decided order.
- **D03 Maintenance:** T4-013 Repair work; T4-019 Attribution.
- **D04 Order without law:** T4-014 Territoriality; T4-015 Live and let live; T4-016 Negotiated order; T4-017 Reciprocity; T4-018 Meta-organization.
- **D05 Collective identity:** T4-004 Frame bridging; T4-022 Flagging the nation; T4-023 Neo-tribes; T4-024 Symbolic boundaries.
- **D06 Host framing:** T4-001 Keying; T4-002 Boundary work.
- **D07 Imprinting:** T4-025 Visibility returns; T4-026 Completion ritual; T4-027 Collective memory; T4-028 Transition.
- **D08 Contention:** T4-020 Repertoire of contention; T4-021 Rivalry.