# LADDER: the coding table from quote to aggregate dimension

Read it to know what each dimension is made of. Quotes are participants' words from several
rooms; the room is named only so the quote can be traced, and you cite only your own room.

## D01 Critical mass

### T4-003 Sensemaking

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-016 explaining what the canvas is | "In case anybody hasn't heard of it, this is reddit's april fools... thing. Coordinates are (460, 153) if you wanna join in the dank memes" [prequelmemes/c0038] | explaining r/place and giving coordinates to join the dank memes | teaching newcomers how r/place worked |
| T3-016 explaining what the canvas is | "This was Reddit's April Fools day event they put on over the weekend." [rush/c0099] | explaining r/place as Reddit's April Fools event | claiming a small Rush place after the canvas closed |
| T3-016 explaining what the canvas is | "I am aware." [Rainbow6/c0309] | saying they already know the server problem | Showing and explaining what was on r/place |
| T3-018 decoding the finished picture's details | "Er det hvem jeg tror det er? r/place" [denmark/c0211] | asking whether a place figure is who they think it is | explaining what is happening and correcting alarms |
| T3-018 decoding the finished picture's details | "You can see r/NASCAR's logo shown in 3D by stacking changes" [nascar/c0187] | showing the r/NASCAR logo in 3D by stacking changes | viewing the logo through stacked changes |
| T3-018 decoding the finished picture's details | "There was thinking that CHIM might be a kind of spoiler for lots of people, and having a reference and the name of the person the image is of sounds like a stronger option." [morrowind/c0036] | arguing that a reference plus Vivec's name is stronger than CHIM | arguing what CHIM says about Vivec and the fandom |
| T3-052 remarking on neighbouring pictures | "Place" [kanye/c0385] | pointing the room to Place | spotting other pictures on the canvas |
| T3-052 remarking on neighbouring pictures | "South East: /r/MadokaMagica & /r/twitchplayspokemon & /r/Quebec & 8uFRqO5T4MB61S2n2920B/lq37Q='s memorial to a friend who passed away" [zootopia/c0176] | naming the neighbours to the south east | mapping the friendly neighbours after the canvas closed |
| T3-052 remarking on neighbouring pictures | "They're practicing the proper bus stop spacing to join nordics." [europe/c0578] | joking that Eesti is practicing Nordic bus-stop spacing | sharing and joking over national canvas pictures |

### T4-005 Mobilization

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-002 calling members in to place | "The American memers will be on for prime time soon. And after that the Australians. We'll get this done." [prequelmemes/c0021] | counting on American and Australian memers to finish the work | calling people in and routing them to Discord |
| T3-002 calling members in to place | "yup, with a few people it should speed up a lot especially since i was on a 20 minute timer earlier." [metroid/c0015] | expecting a few people to speed up work slowed by a timer | pitching in and calling others to the pixels |
| T3-002 calling members in to place | "Lets make it say" [thebluecorner/c0098] | proposing new words beneath the Blue Corner sign | circulating calls and updates to move Blue work along |
| T3-062 recruiting kindred subs to help | "still [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/place/#x=678&y=708)" [dmt/c0009] | reporting the emblem is still here | rallying people to make and keep the LSD DMT emblem |
| T3-062 recruiting kindred subs to help | "Help create the blue aperture logo in place!" [portal/c0044] | asking for help creating a blue Aperture logo | rallying helpers and dividing up the work |
| T3-062 recruiting kindred subs to help | "finally the randia mod was made to feel like shit" [bakchodi/c0220] | celebrating screenshots for humiliating a Randia moderator | taking the fight into other subreddits |
| T3-104 cheering the builders on | "hell yeah!!" [hoodr/c0042] | joining the Hoodr cheer | cheering and joking around the build |
| T3-104 cheering the builders on | "Why do people always say that? Is it like a reference to something?" [cubers/c0028] | asking what one of us refers to | welcoming helpers as one of us |
| T3-104 cheering the builders on | "We'll do our best! Also adding a white flag underneath right cat" [chicubs/c0088] | promising their best and adding a white flag | cheering on the pixel work |
| T3-144 recruiting quietly to avoid attackers | (no concept placed) | | |
| T3-167 timing a mass placement together | "We should also try to schedule a time that most users are free and online to work together to take over space." [penguins/c0089] | proposing a scheduled time to take over space together | asking for one clear place and time to spam it |
| T3-167 timing a mass placement together | "You should make a post in /r/Guatemala that we started" [guatemala/c0007] | asking for a post that says they started | getting more people in and telling the room they started |
| T3-167 timing a mass placement together | "We should have an official post with clear instructions of location and the layout dimensions." [penguins/c0088] | calling for an official post with clear location and dimensions | asking for one clear place and time to spam it |

### T4-012 Collective efficacy

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-036 judging the canvas too full | "Can someone make a smaller version of the kotobomb? 29x29 seems pretty big." [schoolidolfestival/c0089] | asking for a smaller Kotobomb than 29 by 29 | trying to find room for another image |
| T3-036 judging the canvas too full | "the coord is 545, 458, but i think rainbowroad is not giving it up :/" [schoolidolfestival/c0092] | giving the coordinates and saying rainbowroad is not giving them up | trying to find room for another image |
| T3-036 judging the canvas too full | "I heard there was a second place somewhere on reddit. If we could band together there, it'd probably be pretty easy. :3" [schoolidolfestival/c0084] | proposing banding together on a second place | trying to find room for another image |
| T3-059 urging others to give up | "I think we are a bit late, we can always help out r/gunners with their "Tottenham are shit" sign though" [chelseafc/c0108] | saying they are late and proposing help for r/gunners instead | turning away from the crest attempt |
| T3-059 urging others to give up | "Yeah, we might have come into this a bit late unfortunately. Oh well" [raocow/c0025] | saying they came in too late | calling the attempt off and back on |
| T3-059 urging others to give up | "Never." [apocalypserising/c0036] | refusing to give up defending | opening Discord and refusing to give up defending |
| T3-098 questioning the room's canvas presence | "Why don't we have any pixel art on r/place yet?" [minecraft/c0172] | asking why Minecraft has no pixel art on r/place yet | Arguing whether Minecraft pictures counted as r/Minecraft participation |
| T3-098 questioning the room's canvas presence | "But now there is TWO red pandas." [redpandas/c0028] | celebrating two red pandas | keeping our own mark while welcoming more pandas |
| T3-098 questioning the room's canvas presence | "Kinda sad ours is so tiny while HotS managed to make one that can be seen from space :(" [wow/c0357] | being sad that ours is tiny beside the HotS logo | looking back at whether r/wow made a logo and how visible it was |
| T3-136 doubting the room's strength | "again if i find a few people wo whould help!" [sadboys/c0058] | making another wooden horse depend on finding helpers | calling out thin participation and asking again |
| T3-136 doubting the room's strength | "Game is over, but who knows, the admins might make it permanent." [anarcho_capitalism/c0145] | announcing that the game is over while wondering whether it might become permanent | changing targets when the numbers fail |
| T3-136 doubting the room's strength | "It seems we were able to make a break through a row of pixels, so there's hope!" [metroid/c0035] | finding hope after breaking through a row of pixels | defending and maintaining Samus |
| T3-181 quitting the effort under strain | "Aaaaand it's gone" [portal/c0076] | reporting that the Wheatley attempt is gone | giving up and mourning work that did not hold |
| T3-181 quitting the effort under strain | "They had a bot. lame-os" [giantbomb/c0237] | calling the UT bot users lame-os | taking sides on using scripts and bots |
| T3-181 quitting the effort under strain | "Everyone who were working on it got tired of it as it was too stressful." [fivenightsatfreddys/c0480] | explaining that workers quit because it was too stressful | giving up ground and rebuilding somewhere else |

## D02 Coordination without command

### T4-006 Collective representation

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-004 settling the mark's design | "Should we allow these half-life fans to continue making the logo or should we disrupt it?" [tf2/c0235] | asking whether to allow or disrupt the Half-Life logo | Arguing over expansion and what belongs in the design |
| T3-004 settling the mark's design | "April 4: in hindsight, someone in chat suggested to go over Usami, and that would've gone better. I just didn't want to have to destroy existing stuff." [satania/c0079] | saying in hindsight that sparing existing work shaped the failed plan | fitting names and art into limited pixels |
| T3-004 settling the mark's design | "The incomplete plus on the silver egg is bothering me." [puzzleanddragons/c0147] | complaining that the silver egg's plus is incomplete | revising and adding to the finished picture |
| T3-033 proposing the room's mark | "need more people to help!!" [runescape/c0335] | calling for more people to help | Proposing and locating RuneScape marks |
| T3-033 proposing the room's mark | "Forsen Boys in PLACE" [hearthstone/c0311] | putting Forsen Boys in PLACE | putting Forsen Boys in PLACE |
| T3-033 proposing the room's mark | "How would you guys feel about a white outline around BMO?" [adventuretime/c0109] | proposing a white outline around BMO | pitching characters and rallying builders |
| T3-077 animating the mark in timelapse | "Plus this... [](https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/564x/a9/c1/56/a9c1568e5f6327a3cf038835652e2c44.jpg)" [Mario/c0012] | adding another visual reference to the flashing plan | planning to make the toadstool flash |
| T3-077 animating the mark in timelapse | "There is plenty of fighting to get certain images on r/place, but no one has tried to make a flashing or moving image when the whole thing is viewed in a timelapse. **LETS DO IT!**" [Mario/c0010] | calling for a flashing image in the r/place timelapse | planning to make the toadstool flash |
| T3-077 animating the mark in timelapse | "Would be really cool to make a Mario walk across the whole thing, but perhaps for now making the toadstool near the top on the very left flash from completely red to completely green would be a good start :D" [Mario/c0011] | scaling a walking Mario idea down to flashing the toadstool red and green | planning to make the toadstool flash |
| T3-082 finding the room's mark placed | "Where's Wolverine?" [marvel/c0034] | asking where Wolverine is | reporting Marvel marks and pressure on the canvas |
| T3-082 finding the room's mark placed | "I found Lonk on /r/place" [zelda/c0021] | finding Lonk on r/place | showing and admiring Zelda pictures on r/place |
| T3-082 finding the room's mark placed | "Giant transgender flag on /r/place" [transgender/c0011] | sharing a giant transgender flag on r/place | showing and celebrating the flags |
| T3-092 making a tribute alone | "I messed around on r/place and wrote SYD FC. We are a real small sub so theres not really much hope for us to have much more on there, along the likes of Chelsea and Man United haha." [SydneyFC/c0010] | writing SYD FC and sizing the small sub's hopes against bigger clubs | writing a small SYD FC and watching whether it lasts |
| T3-092 making a tribute alone | "Everyone is fighting for corners and I make a wholesome smiley face. :)" [wholesomememes/c0042] | making a wholesome smiley face while everyone fights for corners | making and celebrating small wholesome marks |
| T3-092 making a tribute alone | "A pineapple ate it and then the Mona lisa ate the pineapple." [kingdomhearts/c0085] | saying a pineapple and then the Mona Lisa ate the contribution | showing and losing small canvas contributions |
| T3-160 building memorials to the dead | "We did it bois." [metalcore/c0160] | celebrating that they did it | claiming and celebrating what metalcore made |
| T3-160 building memorials to the dead | "Wie im Titel geschrieben fände ich das angemessen um unseren beistand und trauer auszudrücken." [placeDE/c0274] | proposing Russian colours to express grief and support | making memorials and messages of support |
| T3-160 building memorials to the dead | "putting the Hillsborough flames on r/place" [liverpoolfc/c0085] | proposing Hillsborough flames on r/place | dropping the Hillsborough flames after testing the room |
| T3-169 signing the sub's name | "I'm starting from the end working to the beginning. Each letter is 5x4" [danganronpa/c0031] | building the banner backward with five-by-four letters | trying to put r/danganronpa above Monokuma |
| T3-169 signing the sub's name | "maintain an expanded northern territory and add some more libertarian memes" [placesnek/c0114] | planning expanded territory for more libertarian memes | keeping 'No Step On Snek' while arguing over politics and ownership |
| T3-169 signing the sub's name | "Can we finally all agree on the number of exclamation points? Five it is." [drawhelix/c0036] | settling on five exclamation points | settling the lettering and whether to add r/drawhelix |
| T3-175 adopting a sign others began | "Ainda falaram com alguém do r/Pokemongo ou do r/thesilphroad sobre isso? Fiquei com muita curiosidade mas adorei!" [PORTUGALCARALHO/c0059] | asking whether anyone spoke with Pokémon communities while saying they loved it | explaining how the flag and Squirtle came together |
| T3-175 adopting a sign others began | "Chairman Party Bird leads the Vanguard!" [fullcommunism/c0263] | installing Chairman Party Bird as leader of the vanguard | making Party Parrot a comrade and room figure |
| T3-175 adopting a sign others began | "Pá, alguém desenhou um Squirtle no /r/place. Nós desenhámos a nossa bandeira ao lado. Eventualmente adoptámos o bicho e pusemo-lo a segurar a bandeira. Agora é nosso!" [portugal/c0226] | recounting adopting Squirtle and making it hold the flag | turning Squirtle into a Portuguese hero |
| T3-191 leaving the work unsigned | "We need help [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/place#x=964&y=759), we're trying to draw our mascot" [furry/c0058] | redirecting migration talk to drawing the mascot | switching from scattered targets to the snoo |
| T3-191 leaving the work unsigned | "Is anyone up for trying to type out r/parrots below? I'd need more than just me to try it" [parrots/c0051] | asking for help writing r/parrots below the parrot | trying and then dropping writing r/parrots |
| T3-191 leaving the work unsigned | "We should relocate to the /r/furry_irl area and we can unite and help them out too." [furry/c0046] | proposing relocation and mutual help with r/furry_irl | switching from scattered targets to the snoo |
| T3-197 heeding the creator's wishes | "Ah. Sorry. Ping removed." [parahumans/c0054] | apologising and removing the ping | keeping the canvas project from causing S4hbbQtdz/cRgjTfqcESz5Bj8VM= trouble |
| T3-197 heeding the creator's wishes | "Please don't ping S4hbbQtdz/cRgjTfqcESz5Bj8VM=. He gets enough spam as it is, and just distracts him from important stuff." [parahumans/c0053] | asking people not to ping S4hbbQtdz/cRgjTfqcESz5Bj8VM= | keeping the canvas project from causing S4hbbQtdz/cRgjTfqcESz5Bj8VM= trouble |
| T3-197 heeding the creator's wishes | "Am hearing S4hbbQtdz/cRgjTfqcESz5Bj8VM= would prefer if we kept his name out of it, so focus on the top part and protecting the bug." [parahumans/c0033] | passing on S4hbbQtdz/cRgjTfqcESz5Bj8VM='s wish and refocusing work on the bug | keeping the canvas project from causing S4hbbQtdz/cRgjTfqcESz5Bj8VM= trouble |
| T3-065 building the homeland's flag | "Je sors, mais si vous lancez un truc je serai là dans la soirée." [bretagne/c0022] | promettant d'être là le soir si quelque chose est lancé | appelant du monde et relançant les tentatives |
| T3-065 building the homeland's flag | "Now we really have to do this" [pakistan/c0016] | treating the Indian flag as making their attempt necessary | calling people to make the Pakistani flag |
| T3-065 building the homeland's flag | "I posted this in r/houston to try to get some help." [texas/c0127] | posting in r/houston to get help | Getting the Texas flag onto the canvas |
| T3-113 drawing national emblems | "Tutti gli altri disegni hanno contorni neri che ne risaltano all'occhio" [theitalyplace/c0252] | proposing black outlines to make the Vespa stand out | putting Italian pictures and words on the flag |
| T3-113 drawing national emblems | "Let's make a massive VB can over at r/place!" [australia/c0110] | proposing a massive VB can on r/place | Designing and placing Australian symbols |
| T3-113 drawing national emblems | "Prøvde å lage en til reddit account med temporary email" [norge/c0075] | trying to make another account to place more pixels | making Norwegian things on the canvas |
| T3-041 extending the room's work | "Our Neighbor to the Left Likes Portals Also" [placeportalpattern/c0016] | recognizing that the neighbor also likes portals | working out where the pattern can expand around other art |
| T3-041 extending the room's work | "It seems to have been destroyed! lets get it back!" [dragonquest/c0012] | calling to get the destroyed she slime back | making more slimes and a Dragonlord with coordinates and templates |
| T3-041 extending the room's work | "Suggestion: Commandeer the heart tipped at (635,776) and turn it into a St. Louis City flag." [stlouisblues/c0120] | suggesting commandeering a heart for a St. Louis City flag | adding slogans, skyline, and other St. Louis marks |
| T3-060 adding a personal piece | "we thought everyone was doing it with your consent" [AvoArmy/c0122] | apologizing for a Portuguese avocado made under assumed consent | deciding which avocado changes belong |
| T3-060 adding a personal piece | "Im going to make a rainbow heart in the middle (have already started) is that ok?" [rainbowgrid/c0002] | asking permission for the rainbow heart already started | making and locating a rainbow heart |
| T3-060 adding a personal piece | "It might go better if everyone focuses on making the little pink heart inside then expanding out from that." [TransFlagPlace/c0179] | coordinating the heart by starting inside and expanding outward | adding words, hearts, and other marks to the flag |

### T4-007 Direct information sharing

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-038 building and reporting the mark | "/r/place has ended. Peridot somehow survived." [stevenuniverse/c0454] | announcing r/place ended with Peridot surviving | Reporting, celebrating, and tracking what is on the canvas |
| T3-038 building and reporting the mark | "Now it's just a soul-less logo." [dota2/c0913] | mourning the memes replaced by a soul-less logo | Choosing, drawing, and enlarging Dota canvas art |
| T3-038 building and reporting the mark | "Lets make the gator in r/place, lets do it next to the UF logo on bottom left" [ufl/c0011] | proposing a gator next to the UF logo | planning and building UF marks |

### T4-008 Standardization of output

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-008 messaging individual placers to stop | "I dotted the flag on accident while trying to renovate :(" [traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns/c0012] | admitting to dotting the flag while trying to renovate | patching pixels and correcting the flag |
| T3-008 messaging individual placers to stop | "i knew it had to be you guys doing this. you're the best. i've patched in 3 spots so far" [traaaaaaannnnnnnnnns/c0014] | recognizing the room's work and patching three spots | patching pixels and correcting the flag |
| T3-008 messaging individual placers to stop | "I've been repairing the art and PM-ing users that place grey pixels on top of the art letting them know what the plan is." [necrodancer/c0083] | repairing the art and messaging grey-pixel placers | fighting overwrites and repairing the picture |
| T3-034 asking for coordinates and instructions | "Original thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/place/comments/62xrg2/help_me_add_david_bowie_starting_at_his_chin_x/" [davidbowie/c0008] | pointing people to the original r/place thread | passing around the template, coordinates, and places to organise |
| T3-034 asking for coordinates and instructions | "206,594" [auburn/c0045] | giving the spot coordinates | rallying people around a place and a plan |
| T3-034 asking for coordinates and instructions | "If there's not, the coordinates appear at the bottom left. Zoom out and go to the far right side, about halfway down. Look to the right of the Pikachu and left of the blue water drop or onion. It's just the black head so" [penguins/c0050] | explaining coordinates through canvas landmarks | showing newcomers where and how to place pixels |
| T3-049 complaining the calls are scattered | "I personally suggest moving to the area spanning (788,843) to (828, 888). There is no art that Sora would be covering, and it shouldn't be that hard to defend." [kingdomhearts/c0106] | moving Sora to empty coordinates that should be easier to defend | trying and restarting a Sora sprite |
| T3-049 complaining the calls are scattered | "It seems people aren't coordinated and the place we were going to draw is now filled up." [kingdomhearts/c0055] | saying people are not coordinated after the drawing space fills up | trying and restarting a Sora sprite |
| T3-049 complaining the calls are scattered | "Ya es muy tarde para dibujar la bandera de mexico en r/place? ):" [mexico/c0075] | asking if it is too late to draw Mexico's flag | deciding what and where to draw |
| T3-070 sharing coordinates, templates and how-to | "We need to shift it up 2 pixels. Also the nulls are trying to attack." [floridagators/c0060] | shifting two pixels under a nulls attack | turning the Gator mark into coordinates and a workable drawing |
| T3-070 sharing coordinates, templates and how-to | "As much as we want to - no new submissions can be approved at this point in time." [greenlattice/c1045] | closing new art submissions | publishing maps, battleplans, and approval channels |
| T3-070 sharing coordinates, templates and how-to | "ITS WORKING!! The next pixel next to the white up top should be black to begin the cross going downwards if that makes sense." [darksouls/c0021] | celebrating that it is working and directing the next black pixel | funneling helpers into a workable shared plan |
| T3-091 keeping everyone on one template | "Stop fighting me. I'm trying to outline it black and you're doing grey." [leafs/c0028] | asking a grey outliner to stop fighting the black outline | undoing one another over the design |
| T3-091 keeping everyone on one template | "everything else is black, just use those. Turning everything grey is almost impossible." [leafs/c0026] | arguing that turning the outline grey is almost impossible | undoing one another over the design |
| T3-091 keeping everyone on one template | "It's hard to fill in the space while trying to maintain because of the vandalism" [AvoArmy/c0075] | saying vandalism leaves too little manpower to fill space | deciding which avocado changes belong |

### T4-009 Workarounds

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-027 arguing whether scripts are fair | "and now it's getting vandalized" [naruto/c0127] | reporting that the work is now being vandalized | protecting and repairing the Leaf |
| T3-027 arguing whether scripts are fair | "Not on pc atm, will use script when I'm on." [pakistan/c0123] | agreeing to use the script later | arguing over scripts and where they paint |
| T3-027 arguing whether scripts are fair | "see this https://www.reddit.com/r/DotA2/comments/62z2bg/i_modified_ustanel3sss_script_to_make_it_draw_an/" [dota2/c0937] | directing defenders to the modified drawing script | Running and disputing scripts for shared art |
| T3-028 running scripts for the work | "I get an error: "No module named requests."" [udub/c0017] | reporting a missing-requests error while running the code | running the script on several accounts |
| T3-028 running scripts for the work | "/r/Monero has continued to help maintain your /r/place Emilia graphic. We just updated to V4. Can you please ask anybody still running our script to update?" [anime/c0214] | asking script users to update while r/Monero maintains Emilia | Working out coordinates, scale, and designs |
| T3-028 running scripts for the work | "I was running 6 alts, par voh script jo tha humaara browser mein error de raha tha." [bakchodi/c0240] | explaining that six alts failed because the script errored | running scripts and alts to multiply pixels |
| T3-074 working around the timer | "Those damn swedes are greedy for the whole map." [scp/c0023] | calling the Swedes greedy for the whole map | keeping the mark up against too few pixels and competing work |
| T3-074 working around the timer | "I have zero cooldown in placing tiles" [vegan/c0008] | reporting zero cooldown when placing tiles | learning and stretching the pixel controls |
| T3-074 working around the timer | "someone else made the letters different, i had them all the same before" [androidgaming/c0020] | saying someone changed the letters from their earlier consistent design | defending and repairing the Android logo |
| T3-088 placing beyond the pixel limit | "You can use this script to help" [bitcoin/c0114] | offering a script to help | Automating placement and reconciling script versions |
| T3-088 placing beyond the pixel limit | "getting hit by a lazer from the NZ Kiwi" [anime/c0054] | reporting the MCRN logo getting hit by a NZ Kiwi lazer | Reporting damage and changing canvas state |
| T3-088 placing beyond the pixel limit | "I was helping too. The timer was removed which made it easier, but now it's up again. I'll check back in an hour." [vegan/c0212] | helping while the timer changes and planning to check back | learning and stretching the pixel controls |
| T3-089 switching off stale scripts | "Everyone is using scripts. We're being attacked by scripts. If we don't adapt, we lose." [AmericanFlaginPlace/c0473] | justifying scripts as adapting to scripted attacks | running scripts and fixing scripts that fight each other |
| T3-089 switching off stale scripts | "Here is a script that can be run in chrome to draw a slightly larger **I** in the same position. If we get a few people to run it we should be able to take the space pretty quickly" [uiowa/c0011] | sharing a Chrome script to draw a larger I quickly | running and updating a script together |
| T3-089 switching off stale scripts | "Io sarei favorevole. Non ha più senso continuare espandersi. Però ho paura che finché ci sarà gente con lo script attivo, sarà un bordello sia contenere l'espansione che disegnare 'sta vespa." [italy/c0157] | favoring a Vespa but fearing active scripts will prevent it | automating and disputing pixel work |
| T3-108 sharing one bot target | "and uh, what happened to my post?" [minnesotavikings/c0256] | asking the moderator what happened to the bot post | running, correcting, and arguing over placement scripts |
| T3-108 sharing one bot target | "I wanted to help both tux and arch with [the bot](https://github.com/wijagels/reddit-placebot) that's been going around, so I combined them into one map you can use" [archlinux/c0185] | combining Tux and Arch targets into one bot map | building and updating shared bot targets |
| T3-108 sharing one bot target | "the script is a pixel too high" [utaustin/c0118] | warning the script is one pixel too high | using overlays and scripts to build and defend |
| T3-120 lending accounts to a bot | "I no longer have sole control of the bot, which has been delegated to an organisation containing some of the people who helped contribute, and anyone can now submit PRs to update the target image." [rust/c0162] | delegating bot control to contributors and opening target changes to PRs | turning user accounts into ruplace helpers |
| T3-120 lending accounts to a bot | "The username and password should not be taken by command line, I don't want those things saved in my command history file. I changed this script to prompt and read from standard input." [gatech/c0112] | changing fixTheBuzz to keep passwords out of command history | sharing scripts and spare accounts to keep pixels right |
| T3-120 lending accounts to a bot | "Modified script to fix Buzz in /r/place" [gatech/c0110] | modifying the script to fix Buzz | sharing scripts and spare accounts to keep pixels right |
| T3-168 editing scripts to spare neighbours | "can you disable your script for a while to get this heart in place?" [malaysia/c0147] | asking dcx to disable the script for the heart | switching autorepair off and on for shared work |
| T3-168 editing scripts to spare neighbours | "Working on pinging the correct people to get that portion of the dinosaur ceded to you folks." [rust/c0165] | finding the right people to cede part of the dinosaur | making bot power coexist with neighboring art |
| T3-168 editing scripts to spare neighbours | "But I would be pretty disappointed if we got destroyed by accident after a peace deal got made because one guy forgot to update his script." [python/c0106] | warning that one forgotten script could undo a peace deal | making the Python logo coexist with neighboring drawings |

### T4-010 Backstage decision-making

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-014 moving planning into a chat | "It was a "social experiment" where a blank canvas was presented where users could fill in a pixel every 5 minutes. It became a huge deal, and there were many factions and groups seeking to create, protect, and destroy th" [opticgaming/c0218] | recounting the OG logo as orchestrated in the Reddit Discord | bringing Discord plans back to Reddit |
| T3-014 moving planning into a chat | "If you have the official Reddit app on your iPhone you can simply navigate to /r/place and it should work just the same; all you have to do is tap to zoom in, pick a colour from the bottom, and tap where you want to plac" [pcmasterrace/c0795] | explaining how to place a colour in the iPhone app | coordinating with plans, scripts, bots, and Discord |
| T3-014 moving planning into a chat | "Här urförs planering av flaggbygge. och attcak mit danskarna." [sweden/c0168] | directing flag-building and attack planning to Discord | Moving plans and coordinating the work |
| T3-107 keeping planning in the thread | "inclusive and just post a picture" [dwarffortress/c0140] | asking for inclusive Reddit-side coordination | keeping the work findable outside Discord |
| T3-107 keeping planning in the thread | "We should probably consider adding our subreddit name" [dwarffortress/c0037] | considering adding the subreddit name | keeping the work findable outside Discord |
| T3-107 keeping planning in the thread | "Since /r/dwarffortress is probably too long I just set up /r/armok to redirect people to DF if we want to use it." [dwarffortress/c0061] | setting up r/armok so canvas viewers can find DF | keeping the work findable outside Discord |
| T3-109 arguing which chat to use | "Suggestion: Should we have a universal r/Wales discord instead of multiple irc chats?" [wales/c0052] | proposing one r/Wales Discord in place of multiple IRC chats | moving flag coordination into IRC and Discord |
| T3-109 arguing which chat to use | "Why discord? and not a sane thing like IRC?" [archlinux/c0141] | asking why Discord instead of sane IRC | arguing over Discord, IRC, and Slack |
| T3-109 arguing which chat to use | "help organise this." [wales/c0042] | proposing IRC to organise the build | moving flag coordination into IRC and Discord |
| T3-114 disputing the chat's authority | "official orders for the core" [theblackvoid/c1743] | posting official orders to maintain a core | Contesting leaders, spies, and divided command |
| T3-114 disputing the chat's authority | "Honestly, I would've liked some more representation from the other games but I guess we kind of went with the most obvious smash memes." [smashbros/c0382] | wishing other games had more representation than obvious Smash memes | enforcing and contesting who gets to change the canvas |
| T3-114 disputing the chat's authority | "Discord hat nichts zu entscheiden" [placeDE/c0035] | saying Discord has nothing to decide | moving decisions between Discord and Reddit |
| T3-116 hiding the plan from rivals | "Okay, got it. (443, 19)" [russia/c0025] | accepting coordinates 443,19 | sharing coordinates, codes and tools to place pixels |
| T3-116 hiding the plan from rivals | "Those cucks are here apan ko apni bhasha use karni chaihiye jisse apni strategy na pata chale" [bakchodi/c0118] | asking people to use their own language so opponents cannot learn the strategy | hiding the plan by speaking Hindi |
| T3-116 hiding the plan from rivals | "Yeah I've been cleaning up the left side of the flag." [russia/c0027] | cleaning up the left side of the flag | sharing coordinates, codes and tools to place pixels |
| T3-132 spying in a rival's chat | "At first the void went under us. Then it started eating us. That's all fine. What's not fine is that very soon after your beginning, /pol/ did indeed weaponize you." [TransFlagPlace/c0310] | answering that /pol/ weaponized the Void | recounting and defending the story after it ended |
| T3-132 spying in a rival's chat | "Down with /r/porterrobinson!" [porterrobinson/c0121] | calling for the room's downfall | blaming and fighting XTrill over the logo |
| T3-132 spying in a rival's chat | "Unfortunately they're idiots and post all this information publicly, and since every group was in communication with each other, it failed pretty quickly." [TransFlagPlace/c0321] | crediting communication between groups with defeating false flags | recounting and defending the story after it ended |
| T3-152 announcing what the chat decided | "We have a screenshot!" [lovelive/c0023] | sharing a screenshot of the Honoka attempt | finding space and deciding what to build first |
| T3-152 announcing what the chat decided | "I'm currently contacting everyone who overwrites one of your pixel and linking them our discord. Should work after a while." [archlinux/c0028] | contacting overwriters and linking them to the coordination Discord | coordinating through Discord, spreadsheets, and shared plans |
| T3-152 announcing what the chat decided | "Ni ankaŭ prilaboras tion en la [ĉefa babilejo ĉe Telegram](https://t.me/joinchat/AkaBfzvfqSKs_M-crL-1Uw)." [esperanto/c0020] | working on the design in the main Telegram chat | relaying plans and negotiations through Telegram, Discord and bots |

### T4-011 Decided order

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-066 putting decisions to a vote | "I must apologise, for i was the one who placed down the third flag (for which the purpose is to overwrite the first two with a bigger flag). As i outlined in the other thread. I will help him move if he has to or will le" [thailand/c0095] | apologising for placing the third flag and leaving the frog's fate to a decision | deciding the frog's place and drawing acceptable borders |
| T3-066 putting decisions to a vote | "I agree with you, it's just not the right green. It like more like NoVideo green. It's the only reason I was asking for red." [AyyMD/c0138] | accepting green while objecting that it is the wrong shade | choosing the logo's colours and trying to settle the fight |
| T3-066 putting decisions to a vote | "Rough ideas for expansion. Grow the roots, grow the branches, grow the leaves!" [GrowTheTree/c0002] | circulating rough ideas for growing the tree | growing, regrowing, and redesigning the tree |
| T3-101 putting one member in charge | "jiAPggk+x8m5bwxd/l61z1oUQxA= was a fellow comrade during the button. He is a very good choice for this role!" [PurplePixels/c0165] | appointing a button comrade as Vice Emperor Pixel | appointing overseers and laying down Purple rules |
| T3-101 putting one member in charge | "Three seperate accounts." [TheGreatGreenBox/c0029] | painting through three separate accounts | coordinating through chats, votes and improvised leaders |
| T3-101 putting one member in charge | "Looking for positions to fill!" [PurplePixels/c0057] | posting ‘Looking for positions to fill!’ to rally or deliberate about the purple canvas effort | appointing overseers and laying down Purple rules |
| T3-103 dividing the picture among teams | "Do we have a plan for that?" [NewMexico/c0035] | asking for a plan at the new spot | drawing a workable zia and dividing up the pixels |
| T3-103 dividing the picture among teams | "Sounds good! I started out making the long rays 5 pixels high, short ones 3 pixels, with a 7 pixel cube for the center circle, with yellow around. It's very small pixel art, but NM is a little under-represented numbers-w" [NewMexico/c0009] | specifying a small zia because NM is under-represented numbers-wise | drawing a workable zia and dividing up the pixels |
| T3-103 dividing the picture among teams | "we could probably stretch the main circle all the way left to where the green grid starts." [NewMexico/c0042] | proposing stretching the circle to the green grid | drawing a workable zia and dividing up the pixels |
| T3-121 excluding the room's own vandals | "This is the idiot ruining the blue corner" [orderofthebluecorner/c0038] | publicly blaming a person for ruining the blue corner | policing people said to harm blue or its neighbours |
| T3-121 excluding the room's own vandals | "Perdon, pense que eras otro mas tratando de arruinar el arte ajeno." [argentina/c0180] | apologizing for mistaking a bad pixel for sabotage | policing who belongs, who helped and who gets blamed |
| T3-121 excluding the room's own vandals | "Kinda banned though." [homelab/c0052] | answering a hypocrisy complaint with a ban | moderating insults in the r/place dispute |
| T3-125 saying the room wings it | "Yeah definitely we don't do organize, just go with the flow." [southafrica/c0057] | agreeing to go with the flow | saying they wing it and go with the flow |
| T3-125 saying the room wings it | "Got a discord or somewhere you're coordinating?" [monstercat/c0248] | asking for a Discord or somewhere to coordinate | keeping coordination on the canvas instead of Discord |
| T3-125 saying the room wings it | "Nope, just refresh and click :l" [monstercat/c0249] | keeping coordination on the canvas by refreshing and clicking | keeping coordination on the canvas instead of Discord |
| T3-172 renewing the order's oaths | "I would love to participate in future events and help however I can. So I hope you will accept me." [AprilKnights/c0043] | asking to join for future events and help | Renewing the order for another April |
| T3-172 renewing the order's oaths | "The Purple Commandments." [PurplePixels/c0067] | posting ‘The Purple Commandments.’ to rally or deliberate about the purple canvas effort | appointing overseers and laying down Purple rules |
| T3-172 renewing the order's oaths | "Interesting fact, our first grandmaster was a purple. Welcome to the order!" [AprilKnights/c0044] | welcoming a proud purple into the order | Renewing the order for another April |
| T3-173 holding elections for office | "With the April Fools Event over it is time to begin the election progress." [AprilKnights/c0087] | starting the election once the event is over | Moving from the event into elections |
| T3-173 holding elections for office | "I, the President of the Green Corner, will let you decide on this" [GreenCorner/c0079] | letting a poll decide whether to fight, expand, or move | electing leaders and letting polls decide |
| T3-173 holding elections for office | "A principle of the Green Corner is democracy, always." [GreenCorner/c0106] | defending democracy even during attack | electing leaders and letting polls decide |
| T3-187 handing the work over | "Like a beacon in the night, Spiral spirals on." [SquareSpiral/c0207] | memorializing the spiral as a beacon that spirals on | thanking and recounting what spiralers did |
| T3-187 handing the work over | "But you persevered! Thanks to some incredible people, you rebuilt and now that Place has ended, the Spiral will be preserved forever." [SquareSpiral/c0205] | thanking people for rebuilding a spiral preserved at the end | thanking and recounting what spiralers did |
| T3-187 handing the work over | "It was an honor to work with you guys. We were able to leave a mark." [SquareSpiral/c0202] | marking the end by honoring their shared work | thanking and recounting what spiralers did |

## D03 Maintenance

### T4-013 Repair work

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-005 defending the work against attackers | "dovremmo fare molto di più per difendere Waldo" [theitalyplace/c0287] | calling for stronger defense of Waldo as an outer line | defending and cleaning the tricolour |
| T3-005 defending the work against attackers | "MUST PROTECT**THAT SMILE**" [gamindustri/c0099] | turning protecting the character smile into a defense call | defending the Nep as a war |
| T3-005 defending the work against attackers | "How it feels to defend the hammer and sickle on r/place" [TheFarLeftSide/c0483] | showing how defending the hammer and sickle feels | repairing and defending the Motherland |
| T3-021 watching and repairing the work | "EDIT: Niente da fare, i comunisti hanno violato il patto. Dobbiamo difenderci." [theitalyplace/c0029] | declaring the pact broken and calling for defense | defending and cleaning the tricolour |
| T3-021 watching and repairing the work | "let's keep it white, seems to work fine DEFEND AND MAKE THE LOGO GREEN" [AyyMD/c0014] | telling people to defend the logo and make it green after white seemed to work | keeping, repairing and preserving the logos |
| T3-021 watching and repairing the work | "Por mim investia-se no detalhamento da esfera armilar" [portugal/c0033] | investing effort in detailing the esfera armilar | building and correcting the flag design |
| T3-042 choosing upkeep over expansion | "Progress is also being pushed back because random vandals and people trying to push a green and yellow checkerboard into our space" [hentai/c0103] | having progress pushed back by vandals and the checkerboard | calling it done and keeping defending anyway |
| T3-042 choosing upkeep over expansion | "Ma uitam la steag si cine il saboteaza, majoritatea sunt romani care posteaza aici. Shame." [romania/c0152] | shaming Romanian posters for sabotaging the flag | holding back attacks and overextension |
| T3-042 choosing upkeep over expansion | "focus on creating a strong rainbow core" [ainbowroad/c0402] | refocusing work on a strong rainbow core | Arguing over priorities and what the road should be |
| T3-055 reshaping the mark against tampering | "If we do this and make the R angular it extends the gap and forces them to round out the R into a B NO SYMMETRY on the R" [rutgers/c0128] | ordering no symmetry so attackers must work harder to make a B | redesigning RU to resist becoming BU |
| T3-055 reshaping the mark against tampering | "The black border won't work, we need to have a layer of just back for his mask at the bottom before the border" [ethoslab/c0033] | reworking the black border around the mask | changing the plan to fit and survive |
| T3-055 reshaping the mark against tampering | "we might have to leave the top line all black as it's the border for the design above us and we'd be fighting with it" [NieR/c0092] | leaving the top line black rather than fighting the design above | reworking Emil to fit the canvas and stop friendly fire |
| T3-069 concentrating effort on fewer pieces | "Use the megathread" [israel/c0172] | redirecting another-flag proposal to the megathread | concentrating canvas coordination in Discord and the megathread |
| T3-069 concentrating effort on fewer pieces | "Proposal for official TFLS endgame" [TheFarLeftSide/c0444] | proposing an official TFLS endgame | setting shared pixel priorities |
| T3-069 concentrating effort on fewer pieces | "I am a rational person. I reasoned that the small amount of chaos we contributed was enough to prevent the large amount of chaos that would have been r/place if we hadn't. It was enough to give the artists a force to uni" [theblackvoid/c1889] | saying the Void never lost because it gave artists a force to unite against | Coordinating through plans, roles, polls, and timed orders |
| T3-141 covering the night shift | "Refresh you dunkass, you're probably looking at an old version before I fixed it" [homestuck/c0167] | telling a critic to refresh after fixing the hole | holding, fixing, and defending the Homestuck corner |
| T3-141 covering the night shift | "Might take longer, but if we're quick it might make the night..." [hsv/c0078] | racing to make the logo last through the night | keeping the raute going around people's nights |
| T3-141 covering the night shift | "Unpräzises arbeiten ist nicht zulässig." [placeDE/c0075] | declaring imprecise work unacceptable | cleaning the flag and standing Nachtwache |

### T4-019 Attribution

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-087 tracing who changed the work | "loganmikel ganhador de gold pelo projeto da bandeira do /r/place é um traidor!" [brasil/c0221] | calling the gold-winning flag planner a traitor | policing who may change the shared work |
| T3-087 tracing who changed the work | "We're doing our best to fix the situation." [SquareSpiral/c0126] | saying Brazilians are trying to fix the border situation | separating allies from randos and repairing blame |
| T3-087 tracing who changed the work | "there was a "hanzo switch" there too, but it's gone now. Also the big OSU! logo at the bottom confirmed that they'd help with restoring the pink D.VA bunny." [overwatch/c0847] | reporting Hanzo Switch gone and OSU help for the pink D.VA bunny | reporting Overwatch art being damaged or lost |
| T3-118 blaming moderators for a loss | "I dove back into the hell hole that is iFunny yesterday, just to find out that only mods could post. So this is your fault, I hope you're happy." [dankmemes/c0599] | blaming moderator-only posting for having to dive back into the iFunny hell hole | Blaming moderator-only posting for an iFunny trip |
| T3-118 blaming moderators for a loss | "Little did you know, /r/place was created by capitalists to make everyone *waste* their time on the internet while they sell them ads." [anarcho_capitalism/c0160] | joking that capitalists sold ads while everyone placed pixels | explaining defeat through collectives and a rigged game |
| T3-118 blaming moderators for a loss | "cool. why couldn't you have done that for your caption?" [dankmemes/c0608] | asking why the same correction was not made to the caption | Blaming moderator-only posting for an iFunny trip |
| T3-170 mistaking friendly work for vandalism | "Posted this because there ought to be a solid template for our imprint on /r/place!" [bindingofisaac/c0134] | posting a solid template for the r/place imprint | keeping planned pixels from being erased |
| T3-170 mistaking friendly work for vandalism | "Este rapaz está em panico a pensar que estamos a destruir a nossa parte." [portugal/c0155] | laughing at an outsider mistaking construction for destruction | sorting repairs from damage |
| T3-170 mistaking friendly work for vandalism | "Hey there, please don't try to sabotage the lambda logo that's in the making, it's being coordiante with the Solaire/ DS discord." [darksouls/c0169] | warning against sabotaging the Lambda coordinated on Discord | clearing up apparent sabotage with shared-plan knowledge |
| T3-188 disowning placers outside the plan | "they say they just want to give pixel art a blue background, not just destroy it." [enterthegungeon/c0053] | distinguishing Blue Corner policy from destroying pixel art | separating Blue Corner allies from the people who destroyed the Bullet |
| T3-188 disowning placers outside the plan | "Kinda defeats the point if you have a script, it's supposed to be a community thing." [mindcrack/c0083] | saying scripts defeat the point of a community thing | arguing over who is ruining the work and what is fair |
| T3-188 disowning placers outside the plan | "r/Twice is being erased" [twice/c0136] | reporting that r/Twice is being erased | arguing with Denmark over the pink TWICE space |

## D04 Order without law

### T4-014 Territoriality

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-012 granting a neighbour room | "Can someone in charge of the /r/place Romanian hearts please talk to us? We would like to claim one." [romania/c0191] | asking whoever controls the Romanian hearts to discuss claiming one | making hearts into alliances and refuge |
| T3-012 granting a neighbour room | "Integrating Eiffel Tower with Gogh title bar" [placestart/c0097] | integrating the Eiffel Tower with the Gogh title bar | fitting threatened art into windows, tabs, and icons |
| T3-012 granting a neighbour room | "It can be made larger, and Monster Cat doesn't mind our presence. The void it coming, though." [thailand/c0110] | proposing a larger flag with Monster Cat's tolerance while warning that the void is coming | deciding the frog's place and drawing acceptable borders |
| T3-020 choosing a canvas spot | "Im starting to fill in buffalos with green at 80,200" [seahawks/c0054] | starting to fill the buffaloes with green at 80,200 | settling on a small, defensible design and place |
| T3-020 choosing a canvas spot | "So is this happening? I don't seem to find anything related to the franchise in /r/place" [diablo/c0016] | checking whether the Diablo attempt is happening | finding and moving a place for the D |
| T3-020 choosing a canvas spot | "There's a lot of Zelda art that has been erased. If you look directly to the left of the purple text, you'll see the golden tip of the old triforce. There used to be several triforces around there. There was also a /r/BO" [zelda/c0187] | choosing purple streamer text because nobody seemed to be defending it | negotiating and probing for usable canvas space |
| T3-022 relocating after losing the spot | "Let's just put the logo somewhere else, so these goons don't ruin it." [WPI/c0026] | proposing moving so goons do not ruin the logo | moving and trying again when a spot is taken |
| T3-022 relocating after losing the spot | "although we're being crowded by the Oilers. We could always use more help on this front as well!" [twentyonepilots/c0073] | asking for more help while the Oilers crowd the logo | moving, rebuilding, and stopping when the logo is covered |
| T3-022 relocating after losing the spot | "Estamos perdiendo la batalla contra Bélgica en r/Place pero escuchen." [colombia/c0029] | announcing that the battle with Belgium is being lost | building and repairing Colombia's flag |
| T3-039 yielding space when asked | "Go away, I'm making Commander Video there!" [KState/c0053] | telling the proposed design to leave Commander Video's space | moving when other pictures have the space |
| T3-039 yielding space when asked | "I got an idea how we could maybe merge our Flag with /r/Mindcrack ." [czech/c0057] | proposing to merge the flag with Mindcrack as 68 | negotiating room with neighbouring pictures |
| T3-039 yielding space when asked | "You arent gonna get very far guy. the spot you're trying to build in is taken by multiple other people." [donaldglover/c0064] | warning the BTI builder that the spot is taken | backing off occupied art and parting on good terms |
| T3-045 arguing who was there first | "Well we fought really hard for our flag with our brothers while you stole flags from Poland. We have made love with our neighbor, while you wage wars far outside your own realm." [latvia/c0047] | contrasting Baltic cooperation with Austria stealing Poland's flags | converting Austrian flags and arguing over whose flag it was |
| T3-045 arguing who was there first | "was our original area before it started being sabotaged." [archlinux/c0103] | showing the original area before sabotage | arguing over who crossed the border and who was responsible |
| T3-045 arguing who was there first | "Lemme move goalposts then, messing with another group's work. Given the fact its on the front page of /r/quityourbullshit, its going to have an affect on how the subreddit is seen." [worldpowers/c0017] | moving the complaint from subreddits to another group's work and reputation | arguing over who was there first and what changing pixels allows |
| T3-123 refusing to give up space | "Haha I wanted to do this last night but I got bitched at because people apparently claimed the spot. Wish it was more of a free for all where you can make stuff anywhere without people tracking you down and harassing you" [winnipegjets/c0052] | wishing place were a free for all without claims and harassment | working out who gets which canvas space |
| T3-123 refusing to give up space | "There's not enough peopel working on the r/robotwars sign to keep it constantly up. They lack the manpower." [snsd/c0060] | arguing r/robotwars lacks manpower to keep its sign up | arguing over whose space to respect |
| T3-123 refusing to give up space | "We are willing to give you OSU's space if you help us take them down. They are a menace looking to expand their borders and destroy us all." [uiuc/c0044] | offering OSU's space in exchange for help taking them down | negotiating borders truces and mutual protection |
| T3-124 weighing fighting against moving | "Fuck those traitors. We should honestly move the logo back to the left. /r/kamenrider has been cool with us, and we are destroying their logo with our wings." [detroitredwings/c0169] | urging a move because their wings are destroying Kamen Rider's logo | calling all hands and finding a new home after destruction |
| T3-124 weighing fighting against moving | "Green. They're the only major faction who we are friends with" [PinkUnion/c0009] | choosing green as friends | choosing where to regroup after being wiped out |
| T3-124 weighing fighting against moving | "I'm just glad we were able to keep the Chelsea logo from eating us." [shield/c0085] | celebrating keeping the Chelsea logo from eating theirs | tracking pressure from Chelsea, PCMR, and Starcraft |
| T3-035 asking a host for space | "Please do not build your Logo under your flag, this was not part of our agreement." [maryland/c0100] | objecting that the logo was outside the agreement | negotiating room and permission with Sweden |
| T3-035 asking a host for space | "Thanks! Sorry about earlier :)" [rpi/c0089] | thanking WPI and apologizing for the attack | asking neighbors to share space and keeping agreements |
| T3-035 asking a host for space | "Can we get three in a row to look like the Zelda hearts?" [placehearts/c0311] | asking the heart placers: Can we get three in a row to look like the Zelda hearts? | giving countries, causes, and characters a heart |
| T3-094 disputing who approves a spot | "just let people have fun" [greenlattice/c0830] | rejecting approved-art rules and asking to let people have fun | ruling on what may be built inside |
| T3-094 disputing who approves a spot | "This cube is unapproved. Surround it and then consume it." [greenlattice/c1121] | ordering latticers to surround and consume an unapproved cube | ruling on what may be built inside |
| T3-094 disputing who approves a spot | "permission to put our art on r/place" [twice/c0128] | asking whether art needs permission on r/place | questioning whether canvas art needs permission |
| T3-099 relying on a bigger neighbour | "Looks like it's over. Sorry we couldn't help more." [vinesauce/c0089] | apologizing to Homestuck for not helping more before the end | working things out with neighboring communities |
| T3-099 relying on a bigger neighbour | "we planned a vinesauce text logo next to it but didn't know you guys were building there, sorry about that!" [vinesauce/c0055] | apologizing for painting over the Jets logo | working things out with neighboring communities |
| T3-099 relying on a bigger neighbour | "[Vive la France!](https://www.reddit.com/message/messages/7ypb8n) If we make a small Maltese flag just above the Icelandic one (measuring 8x12) they will help us defend it! edit: we're looking at 406,904." [malta/c0036] | reporting a deal for French help defending an 8x12 Maltese flag | asking bigger neighbours for room and protection |
| T3-162 vetting others' requests to build | "Current Art Project: Banana!" [ainbowroad/c1617] | raising canvas conduct: Current Art Project: Banana! | Setting priorities and authorizing projects |
| T3-162 vetting others' requests to build | "request to build a fractal! it works perfectly on and with a blue background!" [thebluecorner/c0736] | requesting permission to build a fractal | deciding which art stays in blue space |
| T3-162 vetting others' requests to build | "We at r/playrust are trying to build our games' logo, not grief" [thebluecorner/c0991] | asking Blue not to delete the Rust logo | deciding which art stays in blue space |

### T4-015 Live and let live

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-007 urging repair over retaliation | "lets not retaliate. LETS BUILD ANOTHER GODDAMN FLAG." [pakistan/c0135] | rejecting retaliation and calling for another flag | rejecting retaliation and calling for another flag |
| T3-024 refusing to cover others' work | "If we pull that through, we'll destroy someone's Liquicity logo." [monsterhunter/c0075] | warning that Rathalos will destroy Liquicity's logo | working around neighbours and repairing art Rathalos displaced |
| T3-024 refusing to cover others' work | "i can help rebuild it in green" [GreenCorner/c0098] | offering to rebuild the damaged name in green | making room for neighbours, names, and art |
| T3-024 refusing to cover others' work | "Recordad, cuidado con los bordes de otros grupos, tocad sólo los fondos" [epublica/c0044] | telling painters to touch only backgrounds, not neighbours' borders | growing around neighbours instead of over them |
| T3-025 placing rival marks together | "Good old battle of Alberta. Maybe add a VS in between?" [edmontonoilers/c0014] | proposing a Battle of Alberta VS between logos | keeping the Battle of Alberta on the canvas without a war |
| T3-025 placing rival marks together | "fuck the Flames (Just not on r/place)." [edmontonoilers/c0078] | keeping the Flames rivalry off r/place | keeping the Battle of Alberta on the canvas without a war |
| T3-025 placing rival marks together | "hopefully when you guys are done we can have a truce" [edmontonoilers/c0072] | asking for a truce once the Oilers logo is done | keeping the Battle of Alberta on the canvas without a war |
| T3-040 apologizing to neighbours for damage | "You arent gonna get very far guy. the spot you're trying to build in is taken by multiple other people." [donaldglover/c0064] | warning the BTI builder that the spot is taken | backing off occupied art and parting on good terms |
| T3-040 apologizing to neighbours for damage | "Apology accepted my danish friend. I gotta say, absorbing the sins of your people, that's god level." [frankocean/c0228] | accepting a Danish friend's apology | apologizing for the destructive pixels |
| T3-040 apologizing to neighbours for damage | "/r/EdmontonOilers here" [rangers/c0163] | offering Oilers help if the Rangers relocate | bargaining for help and space |
| T3-046 arguing whether covering is fair | "It is inevitable that you get party poopers at every party" [lebanon/c0182] | calling unilateral flag attackers inevitable party poopers | taking other flags and arguing about stealing their work |
| T3-046 arguing whether covering is fair | "Because that's the whole point of the thing lol it's not to keep your little drawing forever it's always changing the longer it's there the more people will want to fuck with it. Basic psychology." [southpark/c0042] | saying constant change and people fucking with drawings are the whole point | saying people fucking with drawings is the whole point |
| T3-046 arguing whether covering is fair | "Can y'all stop seeping into the trans flag" [kanye/c0093] | asking the room to stop seeping into the trans flag | working out room beside neighbours |
| T3-047 making up with another sub | "I'd say just remove everything, no worries. Enjoy your trip." [worldpowers/c0040] | inviting the other moderator to remove everything and enjoy the trip | settling r/place drama with the other subreddit |
| T3-047 making up with another sub | "once the Monster Hunter guys came and spoke to us about it and offered to help save and rebuild" [liquicity/c0060] | saying talk and rebuild help ended hard feelings | making peace after overlapping logos |
| T3-047 making up with another sub | "Can I just say I'm glad in the end there were more good people than bad for r/uk." [ukplace/c0050] | saying the good people ultimately outnumbered the bad | turning the row into banter and thanks |
| T3-076 reining in the room's attackers | "Yeah thats true. Thank you" [warriors/c0133] | thanking them for deleting the post | negotiating borders and pulling back from vandalism |
| T3-076 reining in the room's attackers | "On top of the Waterloo goose ^^^^^/s" [uoft/c0147] | jokingly proposing rebuilding on top of the Waterloo goose | calling for attacks and answering the calls |
| T3-076 reining in the room's attackers | "This greed is going to be destructive." [placestart/c0332] | warning that taskbar greed will be destructive | mocking, condemning, and resisting the taskbar |
| T3-102 defying the call for restraint | "Nah I'm going to hit the bills with green" [nyjets/c0164] | insisting on hitting the Bills after being told no | insisting on hitting the Bills after being told no |
| T3-102 defying the call for restraint | "we have to break the treaty now" [xcom/c0113] | calling to break the treaty | calling to break the treaty |
| T3-119 turning attackers into helpers | "I agree that taking someone else's art may have not been the bast thing to do" [neopets/c0006] | agreeing that taking someone else's art may not have been the best thing to do | backing off the mango and making peace |
| T3-119 turning attackers into helpers | "Us Puzzles and dragon got a nice art thanks to masseffect and 2007scape helping us out." [puzzleanddragons/c0173] | crediting masseffect and 2007scape with helping make the art | bargaining, relocating, and rebuilding with neighbours |
| T3-119 turning attackers into helpers | "I look forward to being peaceful neighbours." [neopets/c0015] | looking forward to being peaceful neighbours | backing off the mango and making peace |
| T3-139 pleading with attackers to stop | "wasting time drawing, erasing (voiding), and redrawing the canvas" [theblackvoid/c1786] | arguing that voiding only wastes drawing time | Arguing over destruction, art, and renewal |
| T3-139 pleading with attackers to stop | "fucking gtfo. nobody cares." [flyers/c0188] | telling the visitor to leave because nobody cares | arguing over who can stop the griefing |
| T3-139 pleading with attackers to stop | "lets give Denmark a fight" [Fez/c0026] | giving Denmark a fight | defending Gomez from trolls and flag builders |
| T3-183 mourning art the room covered | "RIP Mango" [kanye/c0258] | mourning Mango | mourning pictures the Wave displaced |
| T3-183 mourning art the room covered | "First off, that was NOT our original plan. Our original plan (and it has always been) is to defend our existing flag (119, 624) until (156, 655) bordering the pickaxe and the shovel. However, in the night when all of our" [armok/c0039] | denying planned expansion and offering to rebuild the pickaxe and shovel after defending the flag | working out peace, pacts and room with neighbours |
| T3-183 mourning art the room covered | "1 upvote = 1 respect for mango" [kanye/c0254] | paying respect to the displaced mango | mourning pictures the Wave displaced |

### T4-016 Negotiated order

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-010 settling borders with neighbours | "ne dirajte hulka." [croatia/c0099] | ordering people not to touch Hulk | Making truces and room for neighbouring pictures |
| T3-010 settling borders with neighbours | "from /r/rockets here, would love a truce for the both of us" [flyers/c0225] | offering a truce from r/rockets | working out space, repair, and help with neighbours |
| T3-010 settling borders with neighbours | "It's too much. I found a perfect abandoned new spot for us though! New top-right corner: 694, 681" [faeria/c0071] | finding an abandoned new spot after saying the old one is too much | making truces and moving the Yak for neighbors |
| T3-030 disputing how an alliance went | "0-16" [torontoraptors/c0112] | taunting a presumed Lions fan with 0-16 | arguing over the Vikings treaty through NFL rivalries |
| T3-030 disputing how an alliance went | "We had a friendly agreement yesterday...they have turned on us" [phish/c0080] | saying a friendly agreement was broken | arguing over Brazil, defense, and hitting back |
| T3-030 disputing how an alliance went | "I will do as the Empire says, and help who he allies with." [empiredidnothingwrong/c0232] | agreeing to help whoever the Empire allies with | recounting and arguing over who the Empire allied with |
| T3-067 trading away another room's work | "you had to summon the autistic trio to make sure you didnt get downvoted" [thailand/c0155] | accusing UofT of summoning allies for votes | bargaining for space and trading help with neighbours |
| T3-067 trading away another room's work | "How much cross-country love is there for UBC? I don't like that their banner is t-bagging our flag." [thailand/c0175] | asking whether UofT will protect UBC's banner | bargaining for space and trading help with neighbours |
| T3-067 trading away another room's work | "Hahahaha oh man donut good on you for trying this" [thailand/c0154] | cheering a UofT member for trying the negotiation | bargaining for space and trading help with neighbours |
| T3-083 negotiating across a language gap | "'Transláção' para os que não falam bife: -"Espero que não haja grande barreira entre o Espanhol/Inglês... Mas nos no /r/FlagAlliance temos prazer de vos receber em nossa casa."" [portugal/c0122] | mock-translating the alliance welcome for people who do not speak English | making alliances and doing diplomacy |
| T3-083 negotiating across a language gap | "SOMOS UM PAÍS DIPLOMÁTICO E DE QUE TODA A GENTE GOSTA! # **PROTEJAM A BANDEIRA!!!** #" [portugal/c0115] | celebrating being diplomatic while calling everyone to protect the flag | making alliances and doing diplomacy |
| T3-083 negotiating across a language gap | "@DUDE_is_COOL Ok I just [replied to that comment](https://www.reddit.com/r/Quebec/comments/63341u/finir_la_droite_du_logo_patriote/dfr3kf8/) so hopefully they get the message." [RelientK/c0011] | reporting a direct reply to Quebec and hoping the message lands | asking Quebec to leave the AFF dots alone |
| T3-126 disputing who speaks for rooms | "you guys are a bunch of fucking sheep" [thebluecorner/c0008] | calling the blue group sheep | arguing over what Blue should be and who speaks for it |
| T3-126 disputing who speaks for rooms | "We need to appeal to other subs that would work with us. I posted at r/80s. If you can think of anyone else who likely isn't on a project themselves make some appeals." [transformers/c0083] | appealing to other subs that would work with us | working out room and help with other pictures |
| T3-126 disputing who speaks for rooms | "Just place your pixel where you deem it should be." [thebluecorner/c0810] | telling members to place pixels where they deem right amid leadership disarray | arguing over what Blue should be and who speaks for it |
| T3-138 staying neutral between two rooms | "As a Jewish Canucks fan, this is really tearing me apart." [canucks/c0125] | saying the logo dispute tears a Jewish Canucks fan apart | reassuring a Jewish Canucks fan caught between sides |
| T3-138 staying neutral between two rooms | "we would also be happy to fight back the void and the Brazillion torso if we were a part of your space!" [placeportalpattern/c0088] | offering defense in exchange for space for burgie | asking for and returning help across neighboring groups |
| T3-138 staying neutral between two rooms | "We'd appreciate if you guys could send some spare pixels to maintaining the Glorious Spiral" [placeportalpattern/c0034] | asking for spare pixels to maintain the Glorious Spiral | asking for and returning help across neighboring groups |
| T3-149 agreeing truces with rival rooms | "Look, try to help us rebuild and we'll make sure no-one from McGill targets the flag. Deal?" [Russiaclan/c0060] | offering mutual protection if Russia helps rebuild McGill | working out who attacked McGill and keeping the peace |
| T3-149 agreeing truces with rival rooms | "ManningPlace has replied. They are changing their mask to dark grey. Help them." [babymetal/c0093] | telling defenders to help ManningPlace change its mask | making room with touching artwork |
| T3-149 agreeing truces with rival rooms | "Didn't realise kaj was Denmark's just leave the kiwi, it means a great deal to us" [newzealand/c0259] | asking Denmark to leave the kiwi after learning Kaj was theirs | negotiating borders, routes, and peace with neighbours |
| T3-161 mediating between other rooms | (no concept placed) | | |
| T3-193 arguing whether cooperation is surrender | "I think sports can take a step back in this situation" [eagles/c0216] | saying sports can take a step back | weighing a peace treaty with division rivals |
| T3-193 arguing whether cooperation is surrender | "On a surement le meilleur ratio taille de drapeau / utilisateurs actif sur reddit, donc oui, on fait preuve de diplomatie, c'est un peu la force de la France rl sur le plan international d'ailleurs, on est pas aveuglé pa" [france/c0487] | defending diplomacy as the way a small active group held a large flag | arguing whether cooperation means surrender |
| T3-193 arguing whether cooperation is surrender | "S'il vous plaît - aidez en réalisant ce rêve ! Vive la France ! Vive l'Europe ! Vive l'amitié franco-allemande !" [france/c0194] | asking France to realize a Franco-German European dream | arguing whether cooperation means surrender |
| T3-194 acting as envoys between rooms | "Excrevir a preça dà sêmpre niste. Edit: 'Péra lá. Vendo melhor, tens a certeza que a segunda esta mal no contexto da frase? Sei que são quase seis da manhã e estou todo mamado mas parece-me estar bem." [portugal/c0118] | joking through a correction and questioning it at nearly six in the morning | making alliances and doing diplomacy |
| T3-194 acting as envoys between rooms | "Did it happen? I'd totally join in!" [raocow/c0004] | asking if it happened and offering to join | gathering people to make Demo together |
| T3-194 acting as envoys between rooms | "hoping to bring peace to this B1G party we have going on in /r/place" [purdue/c0147] | bringing an Ohio State appeal for peace to the B1G r/place party | approaching Purdue for another community |
| T3-195 holding rooms to their agreements | "The Peace Treaty. Please abide by these rules as the event timer Gets Longer and longer." [AprilKnights/c0022] | asking people to abide by the Peace Treaty | Posting the Peace Treaty again |
| T3-195 holding rooms to their agreements | "r/FTC would like to graciously invite r/FRC to an alliance" [frc/c0061] | inviting r/FRC into an alliance with r/FTC | making room with neighbours and repairing relations |
| T3-195 holding rooms to their agreements | "You guys are removing our beam! Please don't do it..." [xcom/c0041] | asking XCOM to stop removing the neighbours' beam | making room for neighbours and keeping the treaty |

### T4-017 Reciprocity

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-011 helping another room's work | "Same dude. I didn't think I would get involved with /r/furry on /r/place but I just couldn't help it. Snoo is to adorable too be taken over by 100k." [furry_irl/c0143] | saying they couldn't help defending r/furry's Snoo from 100k | giving and receiving help across community boundaries |
| T3-011 helping another room's work | "Don't forget, party parrot is a comrade and an ally of the Motherland!" [fullcommunism/c0181] | naming Party Parrot an ally of the Motherland | negotiating left unity and room for neighbours |
| T3-011 helping another room's work | "G'day cunts" [straya/c0349] | subscribing after helping the parahumans mob and admiring r/straya's art | helping neighbours and becoming mates |
| T3-071 letting neighbours adopt the work | "We at /r/ireland are expanding north but we help protect your logo." [nuclearthrone/c0053] | promising Irish protection while expanding north | making room with Ireland |
| T3-071 letting neighbours adopt the work | "We would like to discuss terms, either movement of the memorial (Which we would be willing to assist with), or its assimilation into our task bar." [metalcore/c0109] | offering movement or taskbar assimilation terms | moving RIP TOM into r/placestart's taskbar |
| T3-071 letting neighbours adopt the work | "Sorry about /r/Ireland destroying your Sub name. I'm trying to repair it but there's too many of us that just want to plow through everything :(" [nuclearthrone/c0051] | repairing the sub name while Ireland plows through it | making room with Ireland |
| T3-072 thanking the room's allies | "Tegime ära, meie lipp on lehvimas ja vene lippu pole ollagi!" [eesti/c0005] | celebrating that our flag is flying | celebrating and thanking people when the flag held |
| T3-072 thanking the room's allies | "we are only 1/4 surviving simple patterns" [placeportalpattern/c0128] | counting theirs among four surviving simple patterns | celebrating and remembering how the pattern grew |
| T3-072 thanking the room's allies | "r/survivor got destroyed." [starcitizen/c0399] | recounting r/survivor getting destroyed | Claiming and contesting the joint victory |
| T3-084 asking other rooms for help | "We just had a vote and we'll help you build the flag on the right of us, but you gotta stop messing with ours" [colombia/c0034] | offering voted help to rebuild if Colombia stops touching Belgium's flag | asking allies for help and negotiating borders |
| T3-084 asking other rooms for help | "if you're not busy, help us out on /r/place so we can have a palestinian flag! Hey guys. Maybe you don't like Palestine, maybe you do. Palestine isn't recognized as a nation by everyone, and all we want right now is a ch" [egypt/c0025] | asking r/egypt to help defend a Palestinian flag | asking r/egypt to help with other r/place work |
| T3-084 asking other rooms for help | "We did this through scripts, and after a mishap causing the letters to appear as "FASI", we succeeded" [acecombat/c0053] | recounting scripting the ISAF logo after a FASI mishap | getting the logo built through Discord and other communities |
| T3-115 turning away another room's request | "Foi pena mesmo, mas eles sabem que são os nossos coños. Quer dizer, hermanos." [portugal/c0308] | calling the Galicians hermanos after the missed flag | answering other groups with help and reciprocity |
| T3-115 turning away another room's request | "No." [wow/c0277] | refusing the request for help | refusing a cross-game logo appeal |
| T3-115 turning away another room's request | "On which side? If it's on the top I maay I have attempted to put a muse logo there.." [radiohead/c0079] | admitting an attempted Muse logo may occupy that side | contesting Muse beside the bear |
| T3-122 sending greetings to another room | "I've decided to also start surrounding the outside of the art with blue so /r/TheBlueCorner will go around it." [gorillaz/c0008] | surrounding the art with blue so the Blue Corner will go around it | working around and helping canvas neighbours |
| T3-122 sending greetings to another room | "Congrats on getting trogdor done! I've been working on the little symbol to the left of you guys." [HomestarRunner/c0093] | a neighbour congratulating Trogdor's builders | welcoming help from the neighbors |
| T3-122 sending greetings to another room | "Dus in principe hebben ze al opgegeven." [PlaceNL/c0149] | saying the neighboring group has already given up | making borders, pacts, and deals with neighbors |
| T3-151 bartering help with neighbours | "People who think we should honor Ireland's attempt at a peace heart." [AmericanFlaginPlace/c0410] | rallying support for honoring Ireland's peace heart | making peace and trading help with neighbours |
| T3-151 bartering help with neighbours | "we are starting to get the r back thank you for your help" [49ers/c0061] | thanking the helper as the r returns | trading help with nearby groups |
| T3-151 bartering help with neighbours | "Thank you so much uwaterloo for helping protect ginger guy from the forsen boys! Thank Mr. Goose" [uwaterloo/c0110] | thanking Waterloo for protecting the Ginger | bargaining over borders and mutual help |

### T4-018 Meta-organization

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-013 gathering kindred rooms together | "We can't do it alone!" [fullcommunism/c0148] | saying they cannot do it alone | organising comrades on Reddit and elsewhere |
| T3-013 gathering kindred rooms together | "It has coordinates. If you want to contribute, please follow this." [archlinux/c0043] | telling contributors to follow the spreadsheet coordinates | coordinating through Discord, spreadsheets, and shared plans |
| T3-013 gathering kindred rooms together | "I'd rather our sub not be advertised to so many people... especially since we know pol and the don are crawling around that place." [asktransgender/c0024] | preferring not to advertise the sub where pol and the don are crawling | moving flag coordination through trans subreddits |
| T3-019 tallying kindred rooms' works | "(also [Lúcio](https://clyp.it/ep5or52u?token=43bc4a6ab7d4466287bcbced992ac44f) too I guess)" [paladins/c0254] | adding Lúcio as another survivor | comparing which game art survived and why |
| T3-019 tallying kindred rooms' works | "See, not even trolls care about us." [paladins/c0270] | joking that not even trolls cared about Paladins | comparing which game art survived and why |
| T3-019 tallying kindred rooms' works | "It's small enough that it should fit right above the UF logo if we take over pacman (which can go anywhere, but UCF belongs with the other colleges in the bottom left corner)." [ucf/c0017] | placing UCF with other colleges by taking over Pacman | putting UCF with the other colleges |
| T3-056 making joint marks with others | "Acuerdo actualizado /r/Vzla /r/colombia /r/ecuador" [colombia/c0057] | announcing an updated three-subreddit agreement | joining Colombia, Venezuela and Ecuador in one long flag |
| T3-056 making joint marks with others | "I got you" [uiuc/c0084] | agreeing to help Wisconsin | asking for and promising help around the B1G corner |
| T3-056 making joint marks with others | "We are happy to have you on top of us, but please, dont invade us :(" [belgium/c0083] | welcoming Belgium above while pleading not to be invaded | negotiating borders and making shared art |
| T3-150 forming alliances between rooms | "I posted on r/The_Donald for them to go after the AnComs to the south" [anarcho_capitalism/c0060] | asking r/The_Donald to go after the AnComs | calling outside allies and Discord for help |
| T3-150 forming alliances between rooms | "We had the same idea. Can you guys start to follow that template?" [uofm/c0063] | trying to put a shared treaty template into use | teaming with Minnesota and making the Little Brown Jug |
| T3-150 forming alliances between rooms | "We became aware of that the void is maybe trying to hit our area next, due to how much blac there is already. This is what they want to attack: [Area](https://i.redd.it/awiw7apq7bpy.png). Since you are right on the middl" [starcitizen/c0278] | asking for cooperation against the void and inviting defenders to Discord | Negotiating and defending shared space with neighboring communities |
| T3-153 meeting other rooms in chat | "https://discord.gg/Pt9bguM" [aoe2/c0115] | sharing a Discord attack-page invite | moving decisions and alignment into other rooms |
| T3-153 meeting other rooms in chat | "I made one for now, not fancy at all." [FederationPlace/c0051] | making a Discord for the group | moving decisions into polls, IRC and Discord |
| T3-153 meeting other rooms in chat | "https://discordapp.com/channels/246867538762268673/297511377843519498" [france/c0101] | sending the existing Discord channel | taking coordination to Discord and other rooms |

## D05 Collective identity

### T4-004 Frame bridging

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-031 playing the room's in-jokes | "i just finished a round of battlegrounds and it had ended by 12 minutes so i couldnt fix it : <" [rwby/c0312] | returning twelve minutes too late to fix it | Looking back on the banner and joking away its flaws |
| T3-031 playing the room's in-jokes | "I helped Germany. It feels good to conquer for a change." [belgium/c0020] | helping Germany and enjoying conquering | turning neighbouring flags into European war jokes |
| T3-031 playing the room's in-jokes | "This is me when trying to finish my IAs.." [ibo/c0020] | comparing the final mark to trying to finish IAs | turning r/place into IB work and programme talk |
| T3-086 carrying in the sub's quarrel | "you have as much chance on place as you do on the blockchain" [btc/c0218] | mocking the proposal's chance on place by comparing it to the blockchain | Carrying the block-size split onto the Bitcoin image |
| T3-086 carrying in the sub's quarrel | "FTC, immortalised forever in the History Of The Internet." [texans/c0122] | celebrating FTC as immortalised | building and contesting FTC while keeping the rivalry friendly |
| T3-086 carrying in the sub's quarrel | "I think someone is doing a black background...?" [morrowind/c0035] | noticing someone making a black background | overwriting and restoring the disputed words and background |
| T3-135 telling clashes as fandom lore | "Brave annexes sov outside EVE" [eve/c0187] | annexing sov outside EVE | doing pixel work as EVE operations |
| T3-135 telling clashes as fandom lore | "LET'S DO THIS" [eve/c0222] | answering the recruiting call with LET'S DO THIS | doing pixel work as EVE operations |
| T3-135 telling clashes as fandom lore | "Someone needs to make Renaissance styled art of our forces riding a whale as we're being defended by a giant Zoro as we fend off the 49ers, while pulling Noire onto the whale." [gamindustri/c0153] | asking for Renaissance art that retells their defense | retelling the pixel work as the Grand Battle |
| T3-179 arguing ideology from the canvas | "/r/place flags show that nationalism is on the rise" [anarcho_capitalism/c0032] | reading r/place flags as nationalism rising | reading politics and property into the canvas |
| T3-179 arguing ideology from the canvas | "It's a pixelated embodiment of collectivism, not just communism." [anarcho_capitalism/c0079] | calling r/place a pixelated embodiment of collectivism | reading politics and property into the canvas |
| T3-179 arguing ideology from the canvas | "/r/thefarleftside will destroy you." [anarchocapitalism/c0004] | threatening that r/thefarleftside will destroy them | trading blame and threats over who destroys whom |

### T4-022 Flagging the nation

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-078 helping kin nations' flags | "Hey man we're fine. We got the top row" [europe/c0647] | reassuring that Croatia has the top row | calling national subreddits into flag work |
| T3-078 helping kin nations' flags | "I live in Texas. Country first IMO." [texas/c0079] | putting country first despite living in Texas | Choosing which other flags to help |
| T3-078 helping kin nations' flags | "TURKEY AND GREECE" [europe/c0738] | putting TURKEY AND GREECE forward | calling national subreddits into flag work |
| T3-079 joining flags with a heart | "Ukrainians payed the price by having their flag vandalized. Not implying it was a bad thing. Congrats." [palestine/c0081] | noting Ukraine's flag was vandalized while congratulating Palestine | making and defending friendship hearts |
| T3-079 joining flags with a heart | "I tried to make it as compact as possible, so-as not to take up too much flag-space." [Russiaclan/c0045] | making the alliance heart compact to save flag space | trying to build the Serbian-Russian heart before time runs out |
| T3-079 joining flags with a heart | "Bu arkadaslarin dis siyaset ve diplomatik yetenegi TC'de yok. Tebrik ederim :)" [turkey/c0188] | congratulating the group for diplomacy the state lacks | making and arguing over the Greek–Turkish heart |
| T3-081 casting fights as national history | "wait till everyone goes to sleep, then go all San Jacinto on their asses" [texas/c0016] | proposing a wait-until-sleep San Jacinto move | Turning Texas sayings and history into calls to fight |
| T3-081 casting fights as national history | "All losers say that" [pakistan/c0248] | dismissing the mockery as what losers say | turning r/place into Indo-Pak rivalry |
| T3-081 casting fights as national history | "Le début de croissant de A+sy0dskwq9oI+crAiB8Bxsdy38= qui est devenu raciste à cause /r/place" [france/c0473] | joking that the croissant feud made loulan racist | turning flags and neighbours into banter |
| T3-085 weighing the room against nations | "We fought pretty hard to make the agreements to get this spot, but I'll try looking for somewhere that's kind of open. You might have to do some begging to move in on someone else's territory." [texas/c0187] | offering to look for open space after fighting for agreements | Choosing which other flags to help |
| T3-085 weighing the room against nations | "Help us Build a Huge US Flag in the Center of Place" [texas/c0095] | asking Texans to help build a huge US flag | Choosing which other flags to help |
| T3-085 weighing the room against nations | "Aiyah let others have a chance" [singapore/c0096] | telling the flag makers to let others have a chance | arguing over whether a flag is worth the effort |
| T3-130 reading national politics in pixels | "Is that a threat? You gonna sit back and watch for a few years while the Europeans have a scrap again?" [de/c0184] | turning a pixel-war taunt into a wartime accusation | turning pixel conflict into arguments about nationalism |
| T3-130 reading national politics in pixels | "Lebanon under French protection .... History repeating itself" [lebanon/c0063] | joking that French protection is repeating history | playing at war while joking about real history and politics |
| T3-130 reading national politics in pixels | "La campagne electorale" [france/c0434] | presenting a borrowed animation as the electoral campaign | sharing and remixing r/place material in ordinary posts |
| T3-142 making ethnic jokes about rivals | "Let's do it! Fucking Croatians." [TheHulk/c0051] | joining the rebuild while condemning Croatians | condemning the people attacking Hulk |
| T3-142 making ethnic jokes about rivals | "les admins ont perdu la tête haha" [france/c0046] | joking that the admins have lost their minds | turning flags and neighbours into banter |
| T3-142 making ethnic jokes about rivals | "Oui mais bon j'ai pas trouvé d'autres affiche qui convenait" [france/c0128] | using a wartime poster because no other one fit | turning flags and neighbours into banter |
| T3-145 feeling national through the canvas | "paziti na ovu prazninu što se širi ispod nas." [croatia/c0076] | watching the void spread below them | Guarding the flag and calling people back |
| T3-145 feeling national through the canvas | "Darf ich nicht beides sein?" [de/c0009] | asking to be both German and European | claiming German and European belonging together |
| T3-145 feeling national through the canvas | "Von wegen Zusammenarbeit, ihr zerstört die französische Flagge, aber lässt die Europäische allein?!" [de/c0032] | accusing the flag builders of destroying France and abandoning Europe | claiming German and European belonging together |
| T3-165 debating friendship with historic enemies | "It did!! I'm glad your guys flag turned out clean as well!" [palestine/c0056] | being glad the other flag turned out clean | arguing whether Palestine and Israel should sit side by side |
| T3-165 debating friendship with historic enemies | "I am a Kemalist and also I love Greece. I also exist." [greece/c0136] | asserting that a Kemalist can also love Greece | arguing whether canvas friendship means anything beyond the flags |
| T3-165 debating friendship with historic enemies | "r/Place was all about community. Any flag for a country that ended up next to another eventually developed a hybrid heart to go along with it. Plus there was alot of support on the sub for it. I'm not saying this should " [greece/c0172] | defending the hybrid heart as right for the canvas environment | arguing whether canvas friendship means anything beyond the flags |
| T3-166 arguing the nation's historical record | "[Humor] Resposta dos Brasileiros ao pedido de ajuda." [portugal/c0186] | joking about the Brazilians' answer to the help request | arguing with former colonies through history jokes |
| T3-166 arguing the nation's historical record | "Quem quis mesmo foi a o herdeiro da coroa portuguesa Pedro IV de Portugal (ou Pedro I do Brasil), entre outros. É uma história complicada, mas está mais para um caso de família que traição." [portugal/c0142] | answering the colonial taunt with a complicated family account of independence | arguing with former colonies through history jokes |
| T3-166 arguing the nation's historical record | "Both sides? like Greeks have anything to be sorry for. Greeks have always been on the right side of history, we have always fought for liberty freedom and justice" [greece/c0171] | denying Greeks have anything to be sorry for | arguing whether Greeks are always on the right side of history |
| T3-180 disputing national belonging | "Let's stop attacking Quebec now and clean up the flag now that they have been run out of the expansion" [canada/c0185] | calling off attacks on Quebec to clean the flag | Arguing Canada and Quebec through the canvas |
| T3-180 disputing national belonging | "Si on est assez fiers pour afficher notre drapeau, on est assez fiers pour l'assumer. Sinon, pourquoi se donner tout ce mal?" [canada/c0456] | saying displaying the flag proudly means owning it | Arguing Canada and Quebec through the canvas |
| T3-180 disputing national belonging | "If you want coexistence and they want war, why are you posting a declaration of war?" [canada/c0296] | asking why a call for coexistence became a declaration of war | Arguing Canada and Quebec through the canvas |

### T4-023 Neo-tribes

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-096 hailing the colour corners | "Wouldn't wanna disappoint God now would you" [popheads/c0066] | pressuring readers to join Team Purple through a fake Ariana claim | calling people to join Team Purple through a fake pop claim |
| T3-096 hailing the colour corners | "Petition to take over r/place collectively and draw a saxophone." [popheads/c0170] | petitioning to take over r/place and draw a saxophone | calling for and answering a collective r/place saxophone |
| T3-096 hailing the colour corners | "THE VOID WILL LIVE ON." [thesimpsons/c0023] | answering the Homer defense call that THE VOID WILL LIVE ON | cheering THE VOID against Homer |
| T3-137 joining an outside group's build | "Step one - defend existing image (already a bit of a challenge)." [catholicism/c0032] | making defending the existing image step one | Following and disputing the crusader shield plan |
| T3-137 joining an outside group's build | "Nobody asked you guys to jump in on it. You're welcome to come, but you self-invited yourselves!" [catholicism/c0044] | telling Catholics they self-invited themselves | Following and disputing the crusader shield plan |
| T3-137 joining an outside group's build | "Hold the ground and fight. If the triangle is over run then I say we align to the hearts and take over the original OSU logo." [PinkUnion/c0035] | holding ground or aligning with hearts after defeat | choosing where to regroup after being wiped out |
| T3-163 defecting from a rival faction | "Join the cause and help us fight the good fight." [greenlattice/c0056] | asking latticers to join Green Corner | joining and preaching the lattice |
| T3-163 defecting from a rival faction | "I had to defend the Glorious" [cgpgrey/c0056] | apologizing for defending other flags instead | choosing between HI, flags, and other factions |
| T3-163 defecting from a rival faction | "So, I'll be furthering the Green Lattice." [greenlattice/c0217] | defecting from blue to further the lattice | joining and preaching the lattice |
| T3-171 spreading a faction's colour | "Our tendrils will breach all obstacles" [theblackvoid/c0285] | declaring tendrils will breach every obstacle | Spreading tendrils and moving or multiplying cores |
| T3-171 spreading a faction's colour | "We erase all flags equally!" [EraseThePlace/c0338] | saying all flags are erased equally | working out what counts as noise and what to spare |
| T3-171 spreading a faction's colour | "Rick's foot is an easy target to start!" [theblackvoid/c0923] | identifying Rick's foot as an easy target | Exploiting weak, dark, or undefended ground |
| T3-174 professing loyalty to a colour | "How y'all doing wanted to know how I could help out" [greenlattice/c0041] | joining and asking how to help | joining and preaching the lattice |
| T3-174 professing loyalty to a colour | "There is only One True Void" [theblackvoid/c1109] | declaring an original core the One True Void | Hailing and embodying the Void |
| T3-174 professing loyalty to a colour | "An Explanation of our Ideologies." [PurplePixels/c0002] | posting ‘An Explanation of our Ideologies.’ to rally or deliberate about the purple canvas effort | rallying brothers and sisters around only purple |
| T3-190 splitting a faction over doctrine | "Fucking nihilists, man" [theblackvoid/c0143] | voicing “Fucking nihilists, man” | Arguing over destruction, art, and renewal |
| T3-190 splitting a faction over doctrine | "Lol why did you think it was ruining it - the black void was central to the experiment. The fact that you don't get this shows your immaturity." [theblackvoid/c0801] | calling the black void central to the experiment | Arguing over destruction, art, and renewal |
| T3-190 splitting a faction over doctrine | "Anyone know why I can't place a tile?" [thebluecorner/c0748] | asking why a tile cannot be placed | arguing over what Blue should be and who speaks for it |

### T4-024 Symbolic boundaries

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-080 arguing over political symbols | "So while we were fighting among ourselves, a European nation came in and slowly took over the individual territories our divided people held." [india/c0503] | likening internal fighting and takeover to divided India | arguing over what the flag should represent |
| T3-080 arguing over political symbols | "Indian politics in a nutshell." [india/c0361] | calling the symbol proposal Indian politics in a nutshell | arguing over what the flag should represent |
| T3-080 arguing over political symbols | "There is a Plan for the Transflag, Going to make it a Celtic band and collaborate with them." [ireland/c0245] | planning a Celtic band in collaboration with the Transflag | working out what goes on the fleg |
| T3-143 judging whether a joke offends | "If you haven't noticed, we don't really care that you are trying to fill in our logo. That's all in good fun! But you just had to say some pretty ignorant and ridiculous things at the same time for some reason." [calgaryflames/c0186] | accepting pixel attacks as fun while objecting to the insults | arguing over fun, trash talk, scripts, and fair play |
| T3-143 judging whether a joke offends | "You guys are taking this way too seriously. It's a fun April Fools day activity. I had no idea that you had this burning hate for me having a good laugh." [calgaryflames/c0185] | calling the attack harmless April Fools fun | arguing over fun, trash talk, scripts, and fair play |
| T3-143 judging whether a joke offends | "I mean... perhaps you need to define "gay touch" as you mean it. My gay friends are always happy when they experience what most people would assume a "gay touch" to be." [rocketleague/c0734] | asking the poster to define 'gay touch' while making a gay-touch joke | arguing over calling the logo's mark a 'Gay Touch' |
| T3-146 covering swastikas and hate symbols | "For some reason somebody drew the Nazi logo on the new Reddit place. Not cool guys." [roosterteeth/c0023] | calling a Nazi logo on the new Reddit place not cool | condemning Nazi symbols and refusing to vandalise related art |
| T3-146 covering swastikas and hate symbols | "For some reason somebody drew the Nazi logo on the new Reddit place. Not cool guys." [roosterteeth/c0022] | calling a Nazi logo on the new Reddit place not cool | condemning Nazi symbols and refusing to vandalise related art |
| T3-146 covering swastikas and hate symbols | "I shall guard it with you." [israel/c0123] | joining another person in guarding the menorah | guarding and repairing the flags and menorah |
| T3-177 calling to draw swastikas | "lets delet it" [dankmemes/c0655] | urging others to delete the r/furry spot | Raiding and taking spots on the canvas |
| T3-177 calling to draw swastikas | "Petition to make the /r/place funhaus logo into a swastika" [achievement_hunter/c0019] | petitioning to make the r/place Funhaus logo into a swastika | contesting FunHaus space with petitions, fights, and swastika jokes |
| T3-177 calling to draw swastikas | "trying real hard to turn the FunHaus logo into a swastika" [roosterteeth/c0063] | trying to turn the FunHaus logo into a swastika | proposing joke changes and provocative pictures |
| T3-182 shutting down bigotry in chat | "I'm not having folks say things that can be taken in any sort of discriminatory context on the sub." [EraseThePlace/c0122] | stopping discriminatory-sounding talk in the sub | policing purity, discrimination, and who belongs |
| T3-182 shutting down bigotry in chat | "nigga sex squidward" [ultrahardcore/c0165] | posting an obscene absurdity | using the day to post offensive and taboo material |
| T3-182 shutting down bigotry in chat | "Meme racista, pá. Vem logo a mim e não diz nada ao vaNgK+9vDEON0ph3A6lvtH4jLJU=." [portugal/c0199] | calling out a racist meme and uneven reproach | fighting over racist abuse and asking moderators to act |

## D06 Host framing

### T4-001 Keying

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-001 staging April Fools fake news | "Surprise--today's date, 4^.1 * 2017, is a minimum of the sine function!" [math/c0043] | claiming today's date is a sine minimum | running April Fools jokes in r/math |
| T3-001 staging April Fools fake news | "Check the date on the article guys." [OnePiece/c0132] | telling fooled readers to check the date | baiting one another with April Fools posts |
| T3-001 staging April Fools fake news | "get baited" [globaloffensive/c0056] | calling the PS3 post bait | trying to fool people with fake CS:GO news and features |
| T3-023 running an April Fools takeover | "Your leader is a liar! Here he is caught red-handed with a non-Twilight plushie! What else is he hiding? /r/MyLittlePony_Rebooted for true fans." [mylittlepony/c0099] | accusing the leader and recruiting true fans to Rebooted | putting on and answering the rooms April Fools jokes |
| T3-023 running an April Fools takeover | "my handunit is a bat now o_o" [fivenightsatfreddys/c0302] | reporting that HandUnit has become a bat | restyling the subreddit for April Fools |
| T3-023 running an April Fools takeover | "this is the second best day of my life" [formula1/c0168] | celebrating the Kimi takeover as a second-best day | turning the subreddit into Kimi and Quokka day |
| T3-032 objecting to April Fools posts | ":/" [wholesomememes/c0035] | answering the timing explanation with a sad face | staging the room’s wholesome April Fools jokes |
| T3-032 objecting to April Fools posts | "YOU'RE THE FUCKING WORST. You got me though." [torontoraptors/c0003] | cursing the prankster while admitting the fake got them | pulling and policing fake-injury pranks |
| T3-032 objecting to April Fools posts | "Who is the guy in the sub's picture?" [naruto/c0020] | asking who is in the sub's picture | making and arguing over the room's April Fools jokes |
| T3-048 reacting to official April Fools | "The next Warcraft movie, will not be live-action, but an animated full CGI spin-off" [wow/c0194] | announcing a fake animated Warcraft movie | spotting, recalling, and explaining April Fools changes |
| T3-048 reacting to official April Fools | "For giving me a Connection Failed in three straight 3-0 games to drop me 150 points and give me an hour ban 😊" [Rainbow6/c0230] | thanking Ubisoft sarcastically for connection failures and an hour ban | Turning familiar game trouble into April Fools |
| T3-048 reacting to official April Fools | "hate horsefuckers" [4chan/c0154] | saying he will still hate horsefuckers | judging and extending what board mergers produced |
| T3-064 spreading the room's joke elsewhere | "https://imgur.com/3UaNMvh.gifv" [drugs/c0078] | answering with an Imgur reaction | passing the smoked-beer joke around Reddit |
| T3-064 spreading the room's joke elsewhere | "/r/me_irl" [kerbalspaceprogram/c0022] | linking the meme to r/me_irl | passing the meme day through other communities |
| T3-064 spreading the room's joke elsewhere | "I'm not from here but we are having a lot of fun thank you guys (TBH I know nothing about LL)" [lovelive/c0006] | visiting from the JoJo subreddit to share the fun | comparing April Fools work across subreddits |
| T3-093 playing with granted moderator powers | "Now we can act like douchebags like the real mods!" [seahawks/c0021] | joking that new mods can act like the real mods | playing with moderator powers |
| T3-093 playing with granted moderator powers | "EVERYONE TAG FROSTBREATH" [ultrahardcore/c0095] | calling everyone to tag Frostbreath | playing at moderators, removals, and subreddit rules |
| T3-093 playing with granted moderator powers | "Unfortunately you can't ban other moderators, so really no one has any power!" [seahawks/c0015] | saying nobody has power because moderators cannot ban each other | playing with moderator powers |
| T3-095 testing others' April Fools claims | "Wir veräußern die Rechte an der Berichterstattung für die Bundestagswahl der Deutschland GmbH." [de/c0163] | proposing to sell the rights to election coverage | performing and judging April Fools jokes |
| T3-095 testing others' April Fools claims | "Fuck you it's still the 31st in the US and dinner time to boot!" [reddevils/c0008] | objecting that the prank arrived before April locally | testing and judging April Fools claims |
| T3-095 testing others' April Fools claims | "what should be our next step to keep this search of dronpes and team in continuity" [thesilphroad/c0316] | asking trainers for the next step in the search | Bringing latecomers into the hunt |
| T3-097 switching off the prank styling | "Er is echt niets liever dan een geitje. Behalve misschien 2 geitjes." [thenetherlands/c0044] | saying nothing is sweeter than one or two baby goats | making the subreddit heilzaam for the day |
| T3-097 switching off the prank styling | "april & fools" [geometrydash/c0033] | tightening the footer joke to april and fools | figuring out and living with the tilted April Fools page |
| T3-097 switching off the prank styling | "I was actually fooled." [smashbros/c0311] | admitting to being fooled | revealing, restoring, and replaying the pranks |
| T3-100 keeping April Fools changes afterwards | "Am I the only one who is disappointed that the mobile version didn't get the same treatment as the PC version?" [rwby/c0071] | being disappointed mobile did not get the PC April Fools treatment | Exploring, performing, and trying to keep the Paint Fools restyle |
| T3-100 keeping April Fools changes afterwards | "k" [starcitizen/c0111] | answering the cursor demand with a run of k replies | Restyling and contesting the subreddit for Wing Commander |
| T3-100 keeping April Fools changes afterwards | "There was also the joke Yasuo rework on Twitter." [leagueoflegends/c1757] | adding the joke Yasuo rework on Twitter | Figuring out and replaying Riot's tricks |
| T3-106 calling a network boycott | "Call Adult Swim and let them know what you think" [samuraijack/c0158] | giving a way to call Adult Swim with complaints | threatening to withhold views over the switch |
| T3-106 calling a network boycott | "i used to watch adult swim and not pirate their content. they said "fuck you" to their fanbase so i no longer care about giving them views" [samuraijack/c0099] | withdrawing views and saying piracy now feels justified | threatening to withhold views over the switch |
| T3-106 calling a network boycott | "i laughed so hard; seriously sound like me. i let adult swim have it on their facebook haha" [samuraijack/c0117] | laughing and saying they let Adult Swim have it on Facebook | threatening to withhold views over the switch |

### T4-002 Boundary work

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-015 routing canvas posts into megathreads | "If we centralize production into this singular area, then we may be able to pull it off." [floridagators/c0041] | centralizing production into one area | pulling scattered r/place talk into one plan |
| T3-015 routing canvas posts into megathreads | "Here - I made r/PlaceStuck for the time being. I encourage all place-related posts to be redirected there" [homestuck/c0178] | making PlaceStuck and redirecting place posts there | complaining about and containing place posts |
| T3-015 routing canvas posts into megathreads | "Hablemos aquí!" [spain/c0055] | moving the talk to r/placeES | moving plans into Discord, r/placeES and one megathread |
| T3-037 arguing the canvas's worth | "Where can someone get an actual explanation of what this loser shit is?" [chicago/c0101] | calling it loser shit while asking for an explanation | arguing about Place posts and city pride |
| T3-037 arguing the canvas's worth | "i am personally very much in favor of dynamism, the place is evolving!!" [rainbowgrid/c0004] | favoring dynamism because the place is evolving | favoring dynamism as the place evolves |
| T3-037 arguing the canvas's worth | "For me the funnest part was spreading the swede flag and the short conquest of the denmark flag. Also defending the commie side and the trans flag." [completeanarchy/c0235] | recounting spreading Sweden, briefly conquering Denmark, and defending communist and trans flags | arguing whether the canvas is spectacle, empire, or harmless fun |
| T3-063 removing canvas posts by rule | "Alright" [lebanon/c0222] | accepting the moderators post-end removal | moving r/place posts into one thread and removing them |
| T3-063 removing canvas posts by rule | "Removed. Thanks for posting, but please take this to r/placecanada" [canada/c0495] | removing the post and directing it to r/placecanada | Concentrating and contesting r/place talk |
| T3-063 removing canvas posts by rule | "Has someone made a sub for Canada to coordinate on /r/place yet?? Posts are being removed in this one." [canada/c0273] | asking for a Canada sub to coordinate on r/place because posts are being removed | Concentrating and contesting r/place talk |
| T3-075 objecting to the canvas flood | "I thought this sub was supposed to be for posting pictures and stories related to weed, not building an army to get a few pixels to be a certain color." [trees/c0485] | objecting that the sub is for weed stories, not building a pixel army | arguing over r/place taking over r/trees |
| T3-075 objecting to the canvas flood | "Yo no los extraño para nada. El sub está mucho más divertido ahora." [argentina/c0372] | saying the sub is more fun without the political threads | arguing over r/place taking over the subreddit |
| T3-075 objecting to the canvas flood | "Just watch the Star Wars prequels. This is a sub about Star Wars prequels. The legend is about HAHA WATCH THE PREQUELS" [prequelmemes/c0680] | telling the outsider to watch the prequels | asking whether r/place still belonged in the room |
| T3-090 opening a canvas sub | "r/singapore has a place on r/place now" [singapore/c0132] | announcing r/singapore has a place on r/place | keeping flag work in one organising thread |
| T3-090 opening a canvas sub | "Please use /r/europeplace for further /r/Place posts" [europe/c0758] | redirecting further r/Place posts to r/europeplace | moving r/place posts out of r/europe |
| T3-090 opening a canvas sub | "Please help us at our sub /r/vcplace" [catholicism/c0131] | moving help and organising to r/vcplace | Moving pixel plans into dedicated places |
| T3-140 moderators disowning the canvas work | (no concept placed) | | |
| T3-184 pausing the sub's usual events | "Gotta help out /r/place stay loopy" [kanye/c0313] | holding off Graduation Survivor to help r/place stay loopy | putting Survivor on hold for r/place |
| T3-184 pausing the sub's usual events | "Now that the flood of /r/place posts is over with, let's resume our regularly scheduled programming!" [coldplay/c0075] | resuming Survivor after the flood of r/place posts | resuming Survivor after the r/place flood |
| T3-185 changing the sub's posting rules | "Temp Rule: posts related to DF art on /r/place will be allowed until the end of April 3rd, UTC." [dwarffortress/c0085] | temporarily allowing DF place-art posts | arguing over place posts and pixel-writing scripts |
| T3-185 changing the sub's posting rules | "Kunne være meget rart hvis den process kunne blive automatiseret en lille smule. Ved i hvert fald at jeg nok ville tage en kommentar lidt mere med et gran salt hvis jeg så den havde sådan et flair." [denmark/c0380] | wanting a flair to automate caution around new accounts | debating trolls, newcomers, and the subreddit climate |
| T3-185 changing the sub's posting rules | "What's the joke? "You thought I was going to show you new stuff but really it's old stuff, hahaha I got you so good."" [magictcg/c0048] | questioning whether the old-stuff switch counts as a joke | Arguing over tags, removals, and prank rules |

## D07 Imprinting

### T4-025 Visibility returns

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-044 recruiting canvas visitors | "hoping to be the Discord server for all green things" [GreenCorner/c0028] | opening a Discord for all green things | recruiting people and moving planning into Discord |
| T3-044 recruiting canvas visitors | "It is generally best to just liquidate as much as you can and travel ceptor, or Blockade Runner\DST a few starter supplies if you have the skills for that. Most can be gotten from TEST_Free or the market." [evedreddit/c0029] | advising the returning player how to move starter supplies | turning the r/place ad into a return to Dreddit |
| T3-044 recruiting canvas visitors | "Thought it'd be a good idea to post some quality old content for any /r/Place people floating about to check out so you'd get a better feel for what our favourite ball-based-browser-game is all about!" [tagpro/c0038] | showing old TagPro content to r/Place people floating about | advertising TagPro through the canvas |
| T3-051 pushing posts up the rankings | "IceFrog. If this gets enough upvotes, this image will show up when you Google search "IceFrog"" [leagueoflegends/c0289] | trying to push an IceFrog image through upvotes | Making vote bargains and pushing jokes up the rankings |
| T3-051 pushing posts up the rankings | "People are trying to claim the MOBA Arteezy plays is FAKE" [dota2/c0586] | trying to put Arteezy's game atop Real MOBA searches | Playing the Fake MOBA image-search fight |
| T3-051 pushing posts up the rankings | "Our Lord And Savior Marc Merrill Has Said If This Post Gets To The Top Of /R/All, He Will Give Us Voice Comms!" [leagueoflegends/c0690] | joining or contesting the Merrill April Fools joke | Making vote bargains and pushing jokes up the rankings |
| T3-053 spelling slogans with post titles | "E" [leagueoflegends/c0929] | posting one letter in a front-page sequence | Lining up fragments into front-page slogans |
| T3-053 spelling slogans with post titles | "BOY" [leagueoflegends/c0861] | posting BOY for a front-page phrase | Lining up fragments into front-page slogans |
| T3-053 spelling slogans with post titles | "ME" [leagueoflegends/c0859] | posting ME for a front-page phrase | Lining up fragments into front-page slogans |
| T3-110 placing a tile as payment | "Je jetterais un oeil je connais pas cette appli. Merci !" [france/c0401] | thanking the Wikipoff suggestion and promising to look | trading ordinary help for a thank-you pixel |
| T3-110 placing a tile as payment | "Ba wikipédia non?" [france/c0395] | suggesting offline Wikipedia reading | trading ordinary help for a thank-you pixel |
| T3-110 placing a tile as payment | "J'irais mettre un pixel sur r/place pour vous remercier." [france/c0394] | promising an r/place pixel as thanks for help | trading ordinary help for a thank-you pixel |
| T3-127 seeking the creators' notice | "Thanks Chad!" [gameattack/c0047] | thanking Chad for the praise | hoping the crew talks about the logo |
| T3-127 seeking the creators' notice | "That would be pretty dope" [gameattack/c0041] | agreeing a podcast mention would be dope | hoping the crew talks about the logo |
| T3-127 seeking the creators' notice | "/r/place DIG logo on Minecraft" [TeamDignitas/c0047] | recreating the r/place DIG logo on Minecraft | getting their logo noticed beyond r/place |
| T3-129 making passers-by notice a demand | "We should give Rick blue pants, do it for season 3." [rickandmorty/c0280] | calling to give Rick blue pants for season 3 | turning season three and Szechuan Sauce into canvas changes |
| T3-129 making passers-by notice a demand | "Szechuan Sauce onto the /r/place canvas for all to see" [rickandmorty/c0329] | forming a strategy to put Szechuan Sauce on the canvas | turning season three and Szechuan Sauce into canvas changes |
| T3-129 making passers-by notice a demand | "We need to mobilize and demand our Mulan sauce back on r/place! I'm thinking the circled area looks good enough." [rickandmorty/c0431] | mobilizing to demand the Mulan sauce back on r/place | turning season three and Szechuan Sauce into canvas changes |
| T3-147 sharing the work's press coverage | "r/tz LUL" [starlightstage/c0120] | laughing at r/tz in the final image | making Akane’s article screenshot into a retrospective |
| T3-147 sharing the work's press coverage | "Ich hoffe wir bekommen dadurch innerhalb der nächsten Woche mehr internationale Aufmerksamkeit." [rocketbeans/c0072] | hoping the taskbar brings international attention | claiming and mocking attention from the taskbar |
| T3-147 sharing the work's press coverage | "[rbtv jetzt auch unter den Top-Ergebnissen bei Google!](https://www.google.de/?gws_rd=ssl#q=rbtv&*)" [rocketbeans/c0155] | mocking the viral claim with a Google-results joke | claiming and mocking attention from the taskbar |
| T3-189 fearing newcomers the mark draws | "Saw the logo and remembered all the time i would spend learning about SPC's and now i'm here." [scp/c0015] | following the visible logo back into the SCP subreddit | weighing who the canvas brings into SCP |
| T3-189 fearing newcomers the mark draws | "we are at war with randia,so we'll have to promote the sub ourselves." [bakchodi/c0277] | promoting the sub themselves because they are at war with randia | using r/place publicity to grow bakchodi |
| T3-189 fearing newcomers the mark draws | "I know you're joking, but consider what happened to r/NoSleep. Too many people trying to submit without bothering to read the rules would make the site admins' lives a living hell." [scp/c0106] | warning that canvas exposure could swamp site admins with rule-breaking submissions | weighing who the canvas brings into SCP |
| T3-196 drawing lapsed fans back | "You could try offloading the old blasters on /r/nerfexchange. As far as demand/pricing goes, prices there are usually a bit lower than eBay prices." [nerf/c0057] | pointing the returner to r/nerfexchange for old blasters | welcoming r/place arrivals into ordinary Nerf participation |
| T3-196 drawing lapsed fans back | "No. This is not still a game. This is so much more than the shadow of what it was back then." [pathofexile/c0176] | telling a returning player the game is more than its old shadow | treating the canvas picture as bringing a player back |
| T3-196 drawing lapsed fans back | "the mural made me really want to play it again, so I bought an Android emulator and got an FE7 ROM and am playing through the game again." [fireemblem/c0440] | replaying FE7 because of the mural | welcoming people through the pixel art |

### T4-026 Completion ritual

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-003 reporting one's own placing labour | "Genuinely made me very happy when I saw it. Thank you!" [Cornwall/c0011] | thanking the placer for making them genuinely happy | celebrating sneaking one on the right before shutdown |
| T3-003 reporting one's own placing labour | "Jalur Gemilang" [malaysia/c0191] | celebrating the final Jalur Gemilang | showing, thanking, and claiming the finished work |
| T3-003 reporting one's own placing labour | "One of my pixels is left on the grey part, I feel so accomplished" [weezer/c0162] | claiming one surviving pixel and feeling accomplished | celebrating and claiming the room's shared pixel work |
| T3-009 celebrating the finished work | "Big thank you to everyone who took part and made this an amazing experience. I've had a blast helping defend all our wonderful works of art with you guys. It's really incredible how many Undertale works were created and " [undertale/c0256] | thanking everyone after having a blast defending their art | celebrating figures as finished or surviving |
| T3-009 celebrating the finished work | "[WE DID IT!](https://i.imgur.com/nJ2inBX.png) ([Clean](https://i.imgur.com/Fe1vibh.png))" [geometrydash/c0009] | announcing we did it | celebrating and correcting what got made |
| T3-009 celebrating the finished work | "Found Fred Flintstone (Sprite from 7 Grand Dad Title Screen) in r/Place!" [giivasunner/c0061] | showing Fred found on r/place | showing and celebrating what made it onto the canvas |
| T3-026 announcing the mark is up | "Edit edit: [This is the final version of the dango](https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/193917094880870400/298415588445782016/image.jpg) before place closed down. Click the link again to see the final version of the d" [Clannad/c0004] | showing the final Dango before place closed down | celebrating and recording the Dango making it to the finish |
| T3-026 announcing the mark is up | "We did something?" [nyu/c0025] | asking what the sub did | finding and showing what got made |
| T3-026 announcing the mark is up | "Dont know if you're new here or not. but we also have this problem." [Rainbow6/c0306] | claiming Rainbow6 shares the server problem | Showing and explaining what was on r/place |
| T3-043 crediting who made the work | "There's a stickied post about it you dumb cuck. Get in there and do your part to protect fuck boy" [wallstreetbets/c0130] | sending a newcomer to the sticky to protect fuck boy | turning the finished figure into collective credit and recruitment |
| T3-043 crediting who made the work | "Thanks everyone especially for helping me out so much with the Mr. Saturn I started on!" [earthbound/c0082] | thanking everyone for helping with the Mr. Saturn they started | celebrating finished work and thanking helpers |
| T3-043 crediting who made the work | "I was a part of that movement, it may be my greatest achievement" [prequelmemes/c0358] | calling participation in the movement a greatest achievement | carrying the finished work into memories and credit |
| T3-157 reflecting on working together | "I'm proud of fanbase and team for making our online presence as big as it can be." [tampabaylightning/c0152] | taking pride in making the fanbase's online presence big | making the little slice stand for the room |
| T3-157 reflecting on working together | "This consuming the entire map within 24 hrs or self-gulaging..." [TheFarLeftSide/c0490] | joking about consuming the map or self-gulaging | celebrating and joking about the pixel fight |
| T3-157 reflecting on working together | "Rivers would be proud" [weezer/c0136] | imagining Rivers would be proud | celebrating and claiming the room's shared pixel work |
| T3-159 rewarding helpers with prizes | "the fruit of our labor, congratulations everyone" [paydaytheheist/c0010] | congratulating everyone on the fruit of their labor | thanking and rewarding the people who made the mark |
| T3-159 rewarding helpers with prizes | "Caught by vMkoO6ecoVYyZFcMZWz6VrN8h00= - **+1 to Ravenclaw!**" [harrypotter/c0033] | awarding one point to Ravenclaw for catching the bot release | playing house Quidditch alongside the canvas |
| T3-159 rewarding helpers with prizes | "also whoever called for the IOI logo to the right of SNSD I love you 4ever" [seolhyun/c0003] | loving whoever called for the IOI logo | celebrating the heart and rewarding the effort |
| T3-164 feeling supported through the canvas | "I think it gives us some sense of identity." [Peru/c0032] | saying the flag gives a sense of identity | saying the flag gives Peru meaning and visibility |
| T3-164 feeling supported through the canvas | "Yeah this just popped into my mind, but are we all trans people or have any cis people helped join the trans flag team?" [TransFlagPlace/c0078] | asking whether cis people helped the trans flag team | making the flag fight mean support and belonging |
| T3-164 feeling supported through the canvas | "Il risultato finale di r/place. Un ringraziamento speciale a r/theitalyplace e r/UnitedKingdomPlace!" [italy/c0279] | showing the final result and giving special thanks to r/theitalyplace and r/UnitedKingdomPlace | exchanging thanks and affection with allies |
| T3-186 celebrating the feat in person | "If anyone would like to go out for dinner/beer or BBQ you should message me! It would be great to celebrate this feat in Person!" [SwissNeutralityZone/c0108] | inviting people to celebrate the feat in person | inviting people to celebrate the feat in person |

### T4-027 Collective memory

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-029 mourning the lost work | "Fez II." [Fez/c0089] | asking Denmark for Fez II | mourning Gomez and making amends afterward |
| T3-029 mourning the lost work | "when you try you best but you don't succeeed" [dankmemes/c0676] | repeating a failed-effort lyric after the placement call | Reporting, mourning, and sharing what happened on the canvas |
| T3-029 mourning the lost work | "Please protect her" [TransFlagPlace/c0276] | asking people to protect the queen beast | mourning and restoring protectors and neighbours |
| T3-073 reporting how the work fared | "The affairs about that navy seals guy in a nutshell" [SwissNeutralityZone/c0076] | summarizing the navy-seals-guy dispute | recounting attacks, disputes, and survival |
| T3-073 reporting how the work fared | "After a truce with r/Denmark, we decided to leave each other's art alone (we didn't finish our "this a cult not a clique" slogan next to our logo to give them space). In the last hour or so of r/place, the Denmark flag e" [frankocean/c0238] | recounting the broken truce and checking the Denmark Discord | closing the event and recounting what remained |
| T3-073 reporting how the work fared | "Final Faroe Islands - Wales area on /r/Place" [FaroeIslands/c0060] | showing the final Faroese-Welsh area | showing what survived and thanking everyone who helped |
| T3-105 saving screenshots and timelapses | "Yup without these guys ^ we'd have had a much harder time. Also a shout-out to Nine Inch Nails (r/nin) for being good neighbors as well" [radiohead/c0287] | crediting neighbors for making defense easier | showing and praising the canvas work |
| T3-105 saving screenshots and timelapses | "Path of exile logo timelapse 72h full" [pathofexile/c0369] | posting the full 72-hour Path of Exile logo timelapse | reviewing the finished canvas and who paid for it |
| T3-105 saving screenshots and timelapses | "Lilac on /r/place" [freedomplanet/c0057] | posting a Lilac-on-place title after the body was deleted | posting Lilac's appearances and saving the final record |
| T3-112 entering the work in atlases | "[Will this do?](http://i.imgur.com/lGldRFH.png)" [fireemblem/c0477] | supplying the requested Kamui image | preserving the mural after placement |
| T3-112 entering the work in atlases | "SPACE NINJA ROBOTS FIGHTING FOR SPACE MUM AGAINST CAPITALISM AND AGGRESSIVE CLONING" [warframe/c0286] | describing Warframe as space ninja robots fighting for space mum | writing the icon into the atlas and crediting GreenLattice |
| T3-112 entering the work in atlases | "There was a Foliat, Sage's Grass starter, somewhere on the left side. It was there for quite a while." [pokemon/c0526] | adding a long-standing Foliat to the memory | Spotting and remembering what the canvas held |
| T3-117 marking the canvas's end | "Who cares" [patriots/c0228] | dismissing the threat with who cares | standing down when placement is over |
| T3-117 marking the canvas's end | "It's over: [r/place has ended](https://np.reddit.com/r/place/comments/6382bb/place_has_ended/) [Here](http://i.imgur.com/OFmF0p9.png) is our final image." [liverpoolfc/c0186] | announcing that r/place ended and posting the final image | marking the ending with final pixels and thanks |
| T3-117 marking the canvas's end | "HULI KA NA !!, TAPUS NA ANG EVENT, UMUWI KA NA, LATE KA NA ng 3 araw !" [philippines/c0560] | telling the builder the event is finished and they are three days late | correcting late arrivals after placement ended |
| T3-148 imagining art the canvas missed | "Effetto place su di me" [theitalyplace/c0353] | sharing place's effect on oneself | telling what the finished canvas meant and might have been |
| T3-148 imagining art the canvas missed | "Didn't know there was a cubing community on Reddit until I saw this!" [cubers/c0308] | discovering the cubing community through the canvas | repairing and circulating a fixed version |
| T3-148 imagining art the canvas missed | "FRC's Finest Moment on /r/Place" [frc/c0138] | remembering FRC's finest moment on r/place | saving a preferred picture of what they made |

### T4-028 Transition

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-054 carrying work to new canvases | "help from xWT8xoHdwjgQakub5i1I/875kBc= and 9mTlmpjTdVJ6FgiwUQQmk/FXj6w=" [rocketleague/c0849] | crediting two friends for helping | recreating the Rocket League logo on Place 2 |
| T3-054 carrying work to new canvases | "https://discord.gg/8vNcZCu We plan on creating a new core for maximum consumption and consuming everything between the cores. 100+ People already. Join us !" [theblackvoid/c1907] | recruiting more than 100 people to build and connect new cores | Carrying the Void onto successor canvases |
| T3-054 carrying work to new canvases | "A blue corner has already started there," [thebluecorner/c1214] | reporting a blue corner already started on pxls.space | trying to carry the Blue Corner onto new canvases |
| T3-057 remaking canvas art elsewhere | "we go back to circles" [osugame/c0712] | joking that osugame goes back to circles | Turning pixel work into osu! jokes and welcoming newcomers |
| T3-057 remaking canvas art elsewhere | "Pls mods" [tf2/c0455] | asking the mods for the flair | Reusing canvas art as sprays, flairs and icons |
| T3-057 remaking canvas art elsewhere | "Glorious PC master race on /r/place timelapse full 72h" [pcmasterrace/c1101] | sharing a full 72h PC master race r/place timelapse | preserving and reusing the finished canvas |
| T3-111 repurposing the canvas sub | "r/place is over we've won that crusade, now what to do with the subreddit." [CKCrusaders/c0081] | asking what the subreddit should do after winning | ending the Crusade and deciding what remains |
| T3-111 repurposing the canvas sub | "submit some of my own posts/images as well to kick-start ​the subreddit." [loliconsunite/c0087] | offering posts and images to kick-start the subreddit | turning the event subreddit into a lasting SFW community |
| T3-111 repurposing the canvas sub | "Austrian, Romanian and Hungarian co-op on /r/place. Please join our Discord to talk." [austria/c0098] | calling Austrian, Romanian and Hungarian cooperation into Discord | moving coordination into Discord and keeping it |
| T3-131 arguing over selling canvas art | "Honest question, why would you need to buy the template?" [heyyea/c0005] | questioning why anyone would buy the template | selling the templates and questioning why |
| T3-131 arguing over selling canvas art | "so after receiving some flack from a few users, rightfully so, G9tcnvgWYlJhFtWKwKEuDJ7KAnk= suggested i do a giveaway. i thought that was a great idea." [kanye/c0460] | making a giveaway after taking flack and RAdd5+syyaBCF+EOiGoc9F0yqGk='s suggestion | answering poster-sale criticism with a giveaway |
| T3-131 arguing over selling canvas art | "by hosting this giveaway people are being directed back to your website." [kanye/c0464] | objecting that the giveaway directs people to the seller's website | answering poster-sale criticism with a giveaway |
| T3-156 adopting the mark as emblem | "There is now a [temporary flair](http://i.imgur.com/U37z0jr.png) for anything related to /r/place." [kirby/c0050] | adding a temporary r/place flair | bringing r/place into the subreddit after and around the canvas |
| T3-156 adopting the mark as emblem | "Guess I have to make this on minecraft now...." [miamidolphins/c0058] | carrying the logo into Minecraft | carrying the Dolphins logo into other forms |
| T3-156 adopting the mark as emblem | "Its late but I just wanted to post what The Yeezus album cover actually is for R/Place" [kanye/c0417] | posting what the Yeezus cover should actually be for r/place | keeping a record of the canvas |
| T3-158 proposing ties beyond the canvas | "My proposal is simple. A crossover post where members of the /r/mylittlepony subreddit read a couple chapters of Worm, and members of /r/parahumans watch just a couple episodes of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic." [parahumans/c0123] | proposing a Worm-for-MLP subreddit exchange | trading Worm and My Little Pony recommendations |
| T3-158 proposing ties beyond the canvas | "Glad you gave it a chance. I'm always glad to hear a polite opinion about the show even if it isn't a glowing recommendation." [mylittlepony/c0231] | welcoming the crossover viewer's non-glowing opinion | trading Worm chapters for pony episodes |
| T3-158 proposing ties beyond the canvas | "Mandatum?" [ireland/c0471] | continuing the aoe catchphrase exchange with Mandatum | keeping canvas friendships going after place |

## D08 Contention

### T4-020 Repertoire of contention

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-006 calling to deface rivals' work | "OK Guys, I'm trying to cut off the Forsen stuff. This is a bit of an act of aggression but they don't need to have the "Boys" part there." [uwaterloo/c0070] | cutting off the Forsen stuff as a bit of aggression | taking shots at canvas rivals |
| T3-006 calling to deface rivals' work | "Dickbutt must die." [EraseThePlace/c0112] | choosing Dickbutt to erase | calling out what to erase |
| T3-006 calling to deface rivals' work | "we have succesfully pushed the pizza men back up into their own corner." [thailand/c0067] | recounting pushing the pizza men back into their corner | calling for more flag space and choosing what to erase next |
| T3-061 pushing into a neighbour's space | "Sto riempiendo quello spazio inutilizzato con i pezzi del tetris, per favore non iniziate a disegnarci altro, grazie!" [theitalyplace/c0050] | claiming unused space for Tetris pieces | claiming and extending Italian space |
| T3-061 pushing into a neighbour's space | "Plans for making a bigger Flag - who has ideas on where and how?" [AmericanFlaginPlace/c0001] | asking where and how to make a bigger flag | arguing over borders, expansion, and keeping the flag pure |
| T3-061 pushing into a neighbour's space | "We are making a Polish flag on r/place. The reddit April fools event. The coordinates are 40.157 Start from the bottom left." [poland/c0002] | giving coordinates and a starting corner for making the flag | starting and extending Polish pictures |
| T3-068 converting a neighbour's art | "ATTACK NOW AND PULVERIZE THEIR CANCEROUS HILA LI PARCHAM LOLOLOLOLOLOL" [bakchodi/c0127] | calling for an immediate attack on the Pakistani flag | calling and coordinating saffron flag attacks |
| T3-068 converting a neighbour's art | "HELP MAKE THE SWEDISH FLAG DANISH" [denmark/c0154] | calling for making the Swedish flag Danish | overwriting rivals and expanding Danish work |
| T3-068 converting a neighbour's art | "Go to /r/place and overthrow the Block M! We shall win" [osu/c0019] | calling everyone to overthrow the Block M | turning Michigan rivalry into canvas attacks |
| T3-128 relaying a streamer's attack call | "Thanks boys didn't see the first post. Thank god 5 other people posted it!" [ice_poseidon/c0163] | sarcastically thanking repeated posters of the call | Answering Tyler1’s call to black out osu |
| T3-128 relaying a streamer's attack call | "*URGENT*MESSAGE FROM TYLER1" [ice_poseidon/c0168] | relaying Tyler1's message as urgent | Answering Tyler1’s call to black out osu |
| T3-128 relaying a streamer's attack call | "behead all osu players the bois are a community of peace" [ice_poseidon/c0151] | joking about beheading osu players while calling the bois peaceful | Answering Tyler1’s call to black out osu |
| T3-176 planting disguised scripts on rivals | "It had such potential for abuse and yet we still managed to carve out a small piece of the tapestry while they were still trying to figure out how to automate the process." [completeanarchy/c0307] | recounting carving out a small piece while opponents struggled to automate | retelling the weekend fight and script trick |
| T3-176 planting disguised scripts on rivals | "Haha, even a layman should have been able to see the pattern in that array of arrays." [utaustin/c0176] | saying even a layman should have seen the script's pattern | recounting and judging taking GiantBomb out from inside |
| T3-176 planting disguised scripts on rivals | "And that's what I did over the weekend." [completeanarchy/c0300] | claiming the script-distrust psyop as their weekend's work | retelling the weekend fight and script trick |
| T3-178 brigading one person off Reddit | "This Ni🅱️🅱️a just asked what's a normie https://www.instagram.com/p/BSZG1EoFJLP/" [dankmemes/c0500] | reporting that the target asked what a normie is | Raiding one Instagram normie after the fiasco |
| T3-178 brigading one person off Reddit | "She dmed me saying whats a "normie" lmao" [dankmemes/c0504] | recounting a direct message from the target | Raiding one Instagram normie after the fiasco |
| T3-178 brigading one person off Reddit | "Done" [dankmemes/c0497] | reporting the raid task done | Raiding one Instagram normie after the fiasco |
| T3-192 griefing the work for fun | "Let's mess with the colonials by continually changing "united kingtom" to "untied kingdom"" [southafrica/c0124] | organising an untied kingdom lettering prank | joking through the pixel wars |
| T3-192 griefing the work for fun | "Traidora! /s Tu também andaste a limpar o resto que eu sei que tu és nacionalista, mesmo não querendo ali o Eder. És cá dos nossos!" [portugal/c0304] | jokingly calling an EDER remover a traitor but still one of us | confessing interference while still belonging |
| T3-192 griefing the work for fun | "All your asexual pride are belong to me." [asexual/c0021] | taunting that asexual pride belongs to them | attacking and rewriting the banner |

### T4-021 Rivalry

| third-order theme | quote | first-order concept | second-order theme |
|---|---|---|---|
| T3-050 trading taunts with rivals | "HAH, it says Cobs now #TAKE THAT YOU DIRTY CUBS FANS" [cardinals/c0101] | celebrating Cobs and taunting Cubs fans | attacking and joking with the Cubs logo |
| T3-050 trading taunts with rivals | "I missed the whole thing and I regret it very much but I wanna know who and why did they want the osu! to get fucked" [osugame/c0810] | regretting missing it and asking why people wanted the osu logo fucked | Raiding, retaliating, and arguing over blame |
| T3-050 trading taunts with rivals | "This is Michigan, we always take the high ground, we're better than everyone else." [uofm/c0229] | joking that Michigan takes the high ground because it is better than everyone | turning canvas talk back into school rivalry |
| T3-058 blaming attackers after the close | "Because idiots were too stupid to make alliances" [forsen/c0083] | blaming the loss on failing to make alliances | arguing who ruined what and why |
| T3-058 blaming attackers after the close | "Denmark. Upvote this so it can be seen when people search for Denmark." [frankocean/c0236] | upvoting Denmark into search results | keeping the Denmark grievance alive |
| T3-058 blaming attackers after the close | "Invading Poland never ends well..." [frc/c0144] | joking that invading Poland never ends well | mourning the loss and arguing who ruined it |
| T3-134 flooding rivals' threads with chants | "BURN THE TRAITOR BURN THE TRAITOR" [osugame/c0376] | jokingly calling to burn the traitor | Raiding, retaliating, and arguing over blame |
| T3-134 flooding rivals' threads with chants | "How was raid planned? Would join too but didn't know.." [osugame/c0759] | asking how the raid was planned after missing it | Raiding, retaliating, and arguing over blame |
| T3-134 flooding rivals' threads with chants | "G O O N" [WPI/c0017] | chanting G O O N in the WPI planning thread | gooning the WPI planning thread |
| T3-154 claiming victory over rival rooms | "De nada, lo hicimos juntos. Felizmente tuve tiempo de terminar la parte de abajo justo a tiempo." [Peru/c0083] | claiming they made it together and finished just in time | thanking each other and celebrating the finished flag |
| T3-154 claiming victory over rival rooms | "If you look closely you'll see that some crafty Cornish snuck their flag under Saint Patrick's flag right before the end." [DevonUK/c0024] | pointing out crafty Cornish placing their flag right before the end | celebrating lasting to the end and longer than Cornwall |
| T3-154 claiming victory over rival rooms | "Current strategy- focus on replacing the green with purple or gold" [lakers/c0062] | repeating the strategy of replacing green with purple or gold | covering Celtics green with purple and gold |
| T3-155 saluting rivals after the fight | "R.i.p. http://imgur.com/a/xXe7t" [vegan/c0261] | mourning the lost spot with an image | celebrating and recounting what survived |
| T3-155 saluting rivals after the fight | "Love the Texans. Our battle will go down in the history books" [texas/c0262] | loving Texans and memorializing the battle | Celebrating what the flag became |
| T3-155 saluting rivals after the fight | "And for the folks in r/CFB, who kicked us out of our original plot: [Image](http://i.imgur.com/lPrXtw9.jpg) Good effort! :)" [vegan/c0373] | crediting r/CFB with kicking them out of their original plot | celebrating and recounting what survived |